REPORT: 13 Nigerian states are broke, lack revenue capacity to fund recurrent expenditure
Total revenue of Lagos, Oyo, Kogi, Osun others not enough to fund recurrent expenditure obligations
THIRTEEN states in the country are not fiscally sustainable and lack the revenue capacity to fund their recurrent revenue in 2019, according to the 2020 edition of BudgIT’s State of the States Report.
BudgIT, a civic advocacy society that uses technology to intersect Citizen-engagement with improved governance, announced the release of the report on Thursday.
The 13 states, according to the report, are Lagos, Oyo, Kogi, Osun, Ekiti, Plateau, Adamawa, Bauchi, Gombe, Cross River, Benue, Taraba and Abia.
The report noted that “13 states in the country, their respective total revenue was not enough to fund their recurrent expenditure obligations (salaries, overhead, debt service obligations) and meet their respective loan repayment schedules that were due in 2019.
The report observed that the development could indicate early signs of distress particularly for states “in this category who have very low revenue generation capacities”.
“Without cutting down certain components of their recurrent expenditure or radically growing their internally generated revenue, the affected states will have to borrow to fund parts of their recurrent expenditure, all of their capital expenditure and also borrow to pay back old loans or service old debts as was observed from their 2019 financial statements,” BudgIT warned in the report.
The report further observed that, out of the remaining 23 states that can meet recurrent expenditure and loan repayment schedules with their total revenue, eight of them have revenue leftovers that are so small (less than N6bn), that they still have to borrow heavily to fund any meaningful capital expenditure.
The worst-hit in this category, according to the report, are Zamfara, Ondo and Kwara who have N782.45m, N788.22m and N1.48bn, respectively.
Observing that the states are currently in financial distress largely as a result of misplaced priorities and soaring debts, the BudgIT report added that based on their fiscal analysis, only five states in the country – Rivers, Kaduna, Akwa Ibom, Ebonyi and Kebbi – are prioritising capital expenditure over recurrent obligations.
“However, the quality of the capital expenditure still leaves much to be desired as explored in the narratives for the respective state profiles,” the report said, noting that the remaining 31 states in the country prioritised recurrent expenditure according to their 2019 financial statements.
“Recurrent expenditures are not necessarily a bad thing, especially when skewed towards sectors like health and education which have expenses like payment of teachers and doctors’ salaries that are recurrent in nature.
“However, of the states in this category, 11 had overhead costs that were larger than their capital expenditures. These 11 states are Adamawa, Bauchi, Bayelsa, Benue, Ekiti, Kano, Kogi, Kwara, Nassarawa Plateau, Taraba,” the report said.
BudgIT further reported that the total debt for all 36 states surged by 162.87 percent or N3.34tn, from N2.05tn in 2014 to N5.39tn in 2019, with 10 states accounting for approximately half or N1.68tn of the increase.
The 10 states that accounted for N1.68tn of the debt increase are Lagos, Rivers, Akwa Ibom, Imo, Kogi, Edo, Osun, Cross River, Kaduna and Adamawa.
Kogi and Adamawa were also in the category of states who spent more on overhead costs for the government than on capital expenditures that directly benefit the people, BudgIT observed.
The report noted that options for further borrowing are reducing for Nigerian states due to safeguards and debt ceilings put in place by the Federal Government to prevent states from slipping into a debt crisis.
The revised 2020 borrowing guidelines published by Debt Management Office stipulated that for states to borrow from the capital market in any fiscal year, their total debt must not be more than 50 per cent of their previous years total revenue.
Based on the DMO guideline, BudgIT noted that for fiscal year 2020, all 36 states will need to pass through the eye of the needle to raise debt from the capital market as they now have total debts as at 2019 which breached the debt ceiling.
However, according to the report, majority of Nigerian states, except Cross River, are still within the debt ceiling that allows them to take on more debt from other sources.
The ceiling for external borrowing is set at a states total debt burden not exceeding 250 percent of their total revenue in or the previous year. Cross Rivers’ total debt of N230.88bn as of December 2019 was 391.91 percent of its total revenue of N58.91bn.
The report also noted that exchange rate volatilities recently triggered by COVID-19 induced shocks have worsened the situation for states who currently have large foreign debt and have also crystallised the risks for those who plan to incur more.
The naira suffered a recent 24.22 percent devaluation from N305.9/$1 as of December 2019 to N380/1USD as at September 2020.
“The implication of this for states is that for every $1 in foreign debt a state owes, it now needs to raise an extra N74.1 from taxpayers to pay it back,” the report said.
Five states with the highest foreign debt burden are Lagos ($1.4bn) Kaduna ($554.78m) Edo ($275.92m) Cross River ($208.96m) and Bauchi ($133.90m).
“Lagos state for example now needs to raise at least N103.46bn additionally from taxpayers over the lifespan of the same $1.4bn foreign debt stock to pay it back due to the devalued naira. That’s less money available for development projects,” the report observed.
BudgIT stressed that dependence on federal allocations portends a bleak future for states as falling crude oil prices, OPEC production cuts and other COVID-19 induced headwinds are set to impact federally collected revenue over the next two years.
It, therefore, urged the states to grow their internally generated revenue.
According to the report, Lagos, Ogun and Rivers will be least affected by dwindling federal revenue due to their higher IGR profiles, while Bayelsa, Borno and Katsina would be the worst hit.
Rivers State occupies the number one position on BudgIT’s 2020 Fiscal Sustainability Index as, according to the report, the state was able to meet its recurrent expenditure with only internally generated revenue (IGR) and value-added tax (VAT).
Painting a bleak outlook for the states, the report noted that “soaring debt burden, imprudent fiscal planning, and nearly a decade of misplaced expenditure priorities have beaten a clear path to fiscal crisis for a majority of Nigeria’s 36 states”.
Noting that states already face significant human development issues, including poverty, unemployment, underemployment, avoidable disease outbreaks (excluding COVID-19) and a host of third-world problems, BudgIT counselled that to address the challenges, “each state needs to, first and foremost, be a sustainable subnational entity” by generating enough revenue to pay its workers, its creditors and still have significant leftover to cover capital expenditure interventions for solving development issues.