Home Blog Page 2690

#NotTooYoungToRun: How Buhari can make history

0

 

By Hamzat Lawal

If there is one thing on which political thinkers all over the world agree, it is the idea that a leader has no glowing legacy or historic impact unless he or she has a robust successor plan. The baton of personalized political principles must be transmitted to a prepared protégé.

However, present day democratic realities have made the world reach a consensus that the best replacement plan is via institutions and policies. The best leaders, therefore, are the ones who, while in office, molded these factors in a way that the next generation finds in them tools that make service to country a seamless exercise.

Now that the Age Reduction Bill, popularly referred to as the Not-Too-Young-To-Run bill, has received affirmative votes from more than twenty-four State Assemblies of the Federation, there is no person on a better advantageous footing to leverage the historic significance of this momentous bill than our own President Muhammadu Buhari.

For those that are yet to know, the Not-Too-Young-To-Run bill seeks to reduce the age for running for elective offices in Nigeria. It was first passed by the National Assembly in a celebrated vote in July 2017. Thus, the amendment as passed by the National Assembly and State Assemblies reduces the qualifying age of the President from 40 to 35; House of Representatives from 30 years to 25 years and State House of Assembly from 30 years to 25 years. The age for the Governor and Senate was retained at the current 35 years.

Undoubtedly, the passage of the bill by the states is very significant, not only because of the extraordinary speed, but because of its legal and moral implications.

With this passage, the bill has met the constitutional threshold prescribed by Section 9 (2) of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (as amended). The Section stipulates that any amendment to the constitution must be approval by at least 24 State Houses of Assembly.

Moreover, given that the chambers of the State Assemblies are the very representatives of the thousands of village squares and the decisions that emanate from them in the nooks and crannies of the nation’s localities, we can assume that the grassroots have spoken. Truly, the masses of Nigeria are on the side of the youth!

What is more, a particular incident in one of the State Assemblies demonstrated that #NotTooYoungToRun is a movement that holds the best of promise not only for young people, but for every guardian of our young democracy.

The interesting development transpired at the Taraba State House of Assembly when, having earlier voted against the bill on 20th December, the House reversed itself on Monday 19th February, and passed the Age Reduction Bill. It was an overwhelming turnaround, as 22 members voted YES while 2 abstained.

I believe, therefore, that it is as gladdening to every Nigerian as it is to me, that we as a people have written our name in gold by showing that political inclusion is possible in our clime.

Nevertheless, with the unprecedented feat recorded so far, the world now seems to be holding its breath as it watches the ball roll over to President Buhari, who is expected to assent to the constitutional amendment. Once the President gives his assent, the bill becomes law. Young people can then run for political office even in the next general elections in 2019.

To be candid, because of #NotTooYoungToRun, President Buhari has a date with destiny. Throughout generations past, men and women in positions of power have rewritten history by singular acts of valor not with the sword but with conscious offerings enacted simply to build bridges that ushered in a new paradigm in socio-political fundamentals.

The peculiarity of a government that came riding on the mantra of “Change” is that Providence has offered it an opportunity to prove its own spirit, as change is a word that signifies an age-input parameter. Posterity can only be kind to soldiers who never reneged on their own revolution. Could it be, that The Almighty has offered this Administration a reason to properly hoist its own flag?

Of course, the #NotTooYoungToRun is a movement that enjoys an emotional and political acceptance across all divides. Hence, in signing the Age Reduction Bill, Buhari could find his finest hour.

But importantly, there are three reasons why President Buhari must take advantage of this opportunity. Firstly, he was recently crowned Africa’s anti-corruption champion by no other than the African Union. What I see in this momentous coronation is the potential for an apotheosis when the president takes advantage of the Nigerian youthful population. Nigeria, being the most populous country in Africa, has a ready-made field for Buhari to mainstream his anti-corruption ethos when he looks towards tomorrow and the youths he will raise to continue the battle he has initiated today.

In signing the Age Reduction Bill, I believe the president will be saying to those that made him the African Anti-Corruption Champion, “I am ready to make politics in Nigeria as inclusive as it can be, because I need to catch them young and train them when they are still trainable. I want to show other African leaders who are still hesitant, that the real Anti-Corruption fight is in the political selection process.”

Secondly, President Buhari served Nigeria as a former military Head of State at the youthful age of 42, and so could easily become the poster boy for generational political transition.

By assenting to the bill, he will be birthing a new era in Nigerian politics, in scoring the psychological goal that his comeback to politics which he was forcefully ushered out decades ago is, perhaps, a mission to reignite the youthful patriotism that motivated him to intervene in politics in the first place. This time around, by signing the bill, Buhari would be taking the pains to fulfill the democratic and legal processes that mainstream Nigerian youths with similar patriotic drive, for good.

Thirdly, immediately after the passage of #NotTooYoungToRun bill in over 24 States as constitutionally required, something remarkable happened as the British High Commissioner to Nigeria, Paul Arkwright immediately took to his official Twitter handle to urge President Buhari to assent to the bill as soon as it was transmitted to him by the National Assembly.

What I saw in this development is that all eyes are on Nigeria. Given that many countries of the world do not give young people the opportunity to play a part in political governance, Nigeria is surely becoming a bastion of modern democratic best practices, with leaders that are determined to make a difference. The diplomatic community and the global society are now waiting for our president to put an icing on the cake by demonstrating a commitment to inclusive democratic ideals. This is because by taking concrete steps to address political inequality and harnessing demographic dividend, the president sets the stage to take advantage of our country’s teeming youth population which if not properly and creatively engaged could equally turn into a demographic disaster.

Lawal, an activist, is currently the Co-Founder/Chief Executive of Connected Development [CODE]. He is working to build a growing grassroots movement of citizen-led actions through ‘Follow The Money’ for better service delivery in rural communities. He is also a leader of the Not-Too-Young-To-Run Movement. He tweets via @HamzyCODE.

A special tribute to advertising guru Ted Mukoro

0

 

By Femi Odugbemi

Theodore Austin Mukoro, aka Uncle Ted, passed on quietly in the morning of 7th March at age 89; great loss for our country and our creative industry. Uncle Ted was a veteran star actor and film producer. He was a writer and a Voice-over artiste. He was also a composer of music. He was a radio OAP back when you had to be seriously schooled in the spoken word to be on air. He went on to play the original “Village Headmaster” in the NTA drama series I grew up watching every Thursday night at 8pm in the late 70s. 

Luckily for me I would personally encounter him years later when I worked in the Creative department of Lintas Advertising in Ikoyi. Uncle Ted was the Creative Director. More than that, he was the heart and soul of the agency.

Oh LINTAS was packed full of larger-than-life characters who have gone on to be leaders in various spheres of life in Nigeria. From Chris Doghudje, to Eskor Mfon, Dele Adetiba, Ron Mgbatogu, Yori Folarin, Stevie Laoye, Tony Ogunlana, Sir.Steve Omojafor, Lolu Akinwunmi and many others. But Ted Mukoro was the ‘mood’ of everyday agency life. His creativity was spontaneous, sustained, spirited and fun. He connected the brand message to the consumer by mining deep the cultural reserves of the Nigerian mind.

The classic commercials he wrote are unforgettable and effective – “Weke weke weke VONO” “BLack thing good Oooo” for Guinness“Shine shine Bobo” for star beer and many others. He was a quintessential advertising man and loved building brands.

But Uncle Ted was also a wonderful caring father. When I joined Lintas in 1987 Uncle Ted’s office was right next to Chairman Sylvester Moemeke’s up on the top floor of 202 Awolowo Road Ikoyi complex. We, the small boys who just began our careers, were kept somewhere on the lower floors and very much down the food chain. But I can’t recall a single week in which Uncle Ted did not wander into our office to tell his Warri anecdotes, make us all laugh deliriously and teach us something useful about the creativity process. Uncle Ted never just entered a room, he blew into it. And whenever he left, there was always more laughter than before he came.

That alone captures my memory of him.

Of course as with most creative people, uncle Ted was a bagful of contradictions. He chain-smoked and drank hard liquor to some inhuman degree. His coffee was drank cold. He loved a lewd joke and his laughter would ring through the building out into the quiet streets of Falomo Ikoyi. But he also never missed morning mass at his church in Maryland Ikeja. He was up to speed in every tenet of the Catholic faith and was almost ordained a Priest!! I almost got whiplash the day he let us young ones into his past calling in the seminary.

In the succeeding couple of decades since I left Lintas, Uncle Ted has remained a presence. Sometimes he would call out of the blues just to chat. Sometimes I would meet him at an event and his memory of times and events and names just never waned. He would ask about so many of my previous colleagues such that I am forced to follow-up to check on their welfare.

Ted Mukoro was a force for good with my generation of creatives who passed through his tutelage. He showed us by example that it was possible to be creative, intelligent, widely-read and widely-connected, and still be human, humble and heart-warming.

May his beautiful soul Rest In Peace!

Femi Odugbemi Tis a former President of the Independent Television Producers Association of Nigeria(ITPAN) and Cofounder/Executive Director of the IREP Documentary Film Festival, Lagos.

EXCLUSIVE: TSA violation, N85m revenue fraud exposed at ministry of trade

 

Of the N1, 482,199,390.87 generated by the Federal Ministry of Trade and Investment between 2012 and 2015 as revenue from payment for trademarks, patents and designs, a total of N85, 106,851.71 could not be accounted for by the Ministry, the ICIR can authoritatively report.

According to a report of an in-depth inspection of revenue records of the ministry instituted by the office of the Accountant General of the Federation, which was exclusively obtained by the ICIR, the ministry remitted N1, 397,092.16 to the government in four years.

The report indicted the ministry, Novalsys Limited, a consultant, and Skye Bank in the shoddy remittance of proceeds from payment registration fees for trademarks, patents and designs.

The report accused the ministry of not keeping proper records for trademarks, patents and designs, and signing an agreement with Novalsys Limited in 2010 for a N200 million contract to develop a web-based registration platform for trademarks, patents and designs without following the 2007 Procurement Act. It also said Skye Bank was insincere in its dealing with the ministry in terms of remittances.

But despite the illegality of the contract awarded to the company, the agreement was renewed in March 2014. Details of the renewed contract could not be traced to the legal department of the ministry, the report further revealed.

“We observed that Skye bank was not very sincere in its dealings with the Ministry in terms of remittances. Record of remittances showed so many discrepancies in the online collections,” the report said

In addition, it said the consultant could not guarantee the remittance of its total online collections to government account, noting that while all revenue collected under the pay direct was remitted to the treasury by the bank, the online version was not fully remitted.

The bank, the report recommended, should be made to refund to government, all outstanding sum of N85, 106,851.71.

It could not be established if the bank had since refunded the amount to the government. Although staff of the ministry abreast of the happenings did not want to be mentioned in the press for fear of victimisation, they told the ICIR that no dime had been paid back by the bank.

The report revealed how the ministry, in violation of the Federal Government’s policy on Single Treasury Account (TSA), maintained a secret account with Skye Bank — run by Novalsys Limited, which later transformed to Einao Limited.

Investigations by the ICIR revealed that Einao Solutions Limited, registered on May 2, 2011, at Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC), does not have anything to do with Information Technology service, unlike Novalsys, registered in 2008 with objectives including rendering communications and system solutions related services.

In January 2016, the office of the Accountant General of the Federation had set up the inspection panel comprising two treasury officers from his office to carry out an in-depth inspection of revenue records of the ministry and also determine the status of Upper Link Ltd, a subsidiary of Einao alleged to be receiving part payment of government revenue at the Commercial Law Department.

This followed a letter from the then Permanent Secretary in the Ministry to the office of Accountant General of the Federation dated January 11, 2016, requesting for an in-depth inspection of revenue records of the Commercial Law Department of the Ministry, based on a complaint the Permanent Secretary received from the Association of Senior Civil Servants of Nigeria in the ministry.

Two treasury officers — Ayeni I.R, an Assistant Director and Bola-Audu I, Principal Accountant — were assigned to carry out the investigation. But, when contacted, Olujimi Oyetomi, Deputy Director of Press at the Ministry of Industry, Trade and Investment, told the ICIR that he did not have the authority to comment on this revelation.

“I’m not in the picture of the issues you were raising and I cannot speak on behalf of the ministry on that,” he said. “Unless the Permanent Secretary authorises what should be released in this respect, certainly, I cannot talk. I cannot conjure up what I don’t know.”

VIOLATION OF TSA POLICY

Despite the Federal Government’s directive that all Ministries, Departments and Agencies (MDAs) should close all their accounts with commercial banks, the Ministry of Trade and Investment still maintains an account (up to date) with Skye Bank, with which payments made for trademarks, patents and designs are collected by the consultant (Einao Nigeria Limited).

Although the ministry and management of the bank had denied the existence of such account on many occasions, arguing that all the former’s accounts with the latter had been closed down in compliance with the TSA policy, unsuspecting members of the public are still made to pay into Account Number 1770393883 for trademarks, patents and designs registration.

Findings by the ICIR show that while the management of Skye Bank, through a letter dated September 7, 2017, addressed to the Special Presidential Investigation Panel on the Recovery of Public Property, claimed that the account had been closed down since June 3, 2016, there was still evidence of payments into the same account as of October 2017.

Earlier, on January 11, 2016, the management of the bank wrote to the Director of Finance and Accounts of the ministry, saying it had closed down all its accounts, including the one for e-collection of payments for trademarks, patent and designs and the balances duly transferred to the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN).

On September 12, 2017 Aminu Aliyu Bisalla, the then Permanent Secretary of the ministry, wrote a letter of complaint titled ‘Breach of TSA Policy by Skye Bank Plc’, to the Governor of Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN). In the letter, he argued that the ministry, in compliance with the presidential directive on TSA, had duly closed down all accounts with the commercial banks since the inception of the directive.

Bisalla said further confirmation of same was made by the bank to the ministry through a letter dated January 11, 2016. He implored the Governor of CBN to take immediate action on the breach by the bank.

However, in October and November 2017, the bank received in the account in the name of the ministry a total of N20, 625,500 and N22, 609,500 respectively.

While the department is using two methods of revenue collection – online registration that is managed by Einao Nigeria Limited and, the direct payment – revenue generated is shared at the ratio of 80:20 at Skye Bank at the end of every month.

The report indicated that the ministry could not trace who instructed the management of Skye Bank on 80 percent remittance to the Federal Government account and 20 percent deduction for the ministry.

It further disclosed that the 20 percent share of the revenue going to the ministry from collection had no approval, noting that what was termed approval which was given by former President Olusegun Obasanjo was for a specific period which elapsed in 2012.

Though, the consultant could not present the total number of applications received, processed and approved since it was engaged to collect revenue on behalf of the government through the online platform, the online payment portal has continued to be operative.

The ICIR gathered that management of the ministry had taken no action to either stop the online payment and collection by the consultant, or close down the account with the Skye Bank.

The panel report recommended the closure of the account number 1770393883 with the Skye Bank on online payment platform managed by NOVALSYS/ Einao for revenue collection. This is despite numerous memos purportedly written by William Amuga, erstwhile Registrar of Department of Commercial Law, on it to Okechukwu Enelama, Minister of Trade and Investment, and the directive by the Presidential Committee on Asset Recovery for its closure.

Another report submitted to the minister by J.K. Ehicheoya, legal adviser of the ministry, recommended the termination of the contract with the consultant as a result of many infractions committed in the collection of fees for the ministry.

While the Minister promised to reform the Department of Commercial Law after receiving the report, the only reform noticeable was the transfer of the Registrar to the Office of the Head of Service of the federation, while the consultant continued receiving payments on behalf of the government.

 TRANSFER OF REGISTRAR OF COMMERCIAL LAW DEPARTMENT

For his insistence that the collection of revenue through the online platform into the account number 1770393883 with Skye Bank be stopped, Amuga William, Registrar of the Department of Commercial Law, was transferred from the Ministry to the Office of the Head of Service of the Federation in clear violation of the extant Federal Government Service Rules.

He was posted to head a non-existing Special Duties Department at the office of the Head of Service of the Federation. When he was first posted outside the ministry in 2011, the Head of Service of the Federation, in a letter dated August, 8, 2011 wrote that the posting did not fall within its purview but that of the Federal Ministry of Justice. It was advised that he should be returned to the latter for further deployment.

The office of the HoS had advised against removal of Assistant Registrar of the department whose duty, according to Cap 436 and 344 of the Laws of of the Federation of Nigeria 1999 is “the administration and registration of industrial property, otherwise known as trademarks, patent and designs”.

Investigations by the ICIR revealed that William wrote several memos to Aminu Bisalla, Permanent Secretary of the ministry, and Okechukwu Enelamah, Minister of Trade,urging them to look into the illegality of the consultant collecting revenue when the contract had expired and also the TSA policy violation.

In one of such memos obtained by our correspondent, William detailed all factors militating against optimal performance of the registry of trademarks, patents and designs in the Department of Commercial Law.

In the memo, dated March 16, 2017, where he pointed out 14 issues, the Registrar wrote: “In compliance with the TSA policy, we have confirmed with the Ministry’s Accounts Department that all of our Bank Accounts with commercial banks in the name of the Federal Ministry of Trade and Investment have been closed down,

“However, the fee being collected on behalf of government by the consultant has been going into an account purportedly in the name of Federal Ministry of Commerce with Skye Bank with Account Number 1770393883.

This is against the policy of direct payment into the government TSA.”

He had on November 20, 2015 directed the consultant, Einao Solutions Limited to suspend collection of revenue on behalf of the Ministry, arguing that such online collection by the consultant was not in line with the TSA policy.

But the Permanent Secretary, who reportedly reprimanded Amuga for issuing such suspension directive without his approval, ordered him to withdraw it.

Thus, five days after the first directive, a withdrawal of suspension memo was issued by the Registrar to the consultant.

INVESTIGATION: How senators took bribes to pass Peace Corps Bill

0

 

This investigation by Premium Times was first published in July 2017. It is republished here with permission, following the President’s refusal to sign the bill into law.


By Samuel Ogundipe

To pass the Nigerian Peace Corps Bill, senators received kickbacks in form of job slots and cash reward from the promoters of the proposed paramilitary organisation, PREMIUM TIMES can report.

Scores of senators received at least seven employment slots each to back the bill, which was passed to, amongst other things, create the Nigerian Peace Corps as the country’s newest law enforcement agency.

Some of the lawmakers considered key to the passage of the law got as much as 500 slots, our findings show.

Other senators received cash rewards for their acquiescence, multiple senators, including those who benefited, sources told PREMIUM TIMES.

The bribery scheme became so brazen that some senators who were members of the committees that worked on the bill pointedly accused each other of being bought by the Peace Corps.

But the leadership of the Senate quickly weighed in, made peace amongst the feuding senators and hushed up the case, consequently saving the upper chamber from another major embarrassment, our sources said.

The Peace Corps, however, denied offering bribes to lawmakers to secure the major milestone in its decade-long quest to become a government agency.

“At no point did our organisation offered any bribes to lawmakers,” Milicent Umoru, the group’s spokesperson, told PREMIUM TIMES. “The bill actually suffered a whole lot before it was finally adopted a few days ago.”

Both chambers of the National Assembly passed the bill “because they see it as necessary to curb acute unemployment amongst Nigerian youth,” she added.

It remains unclear whether members of the House of Representatives also took bribes to pass the bill.

The Senate approved the harmonised version of the controversial bill on Tuesday, despite deep scepticism from its own Committee on Judiciary, Human Rights and Legal Matters that the bill offers virtually no unique service to the public.

David Umaru

David Umaru, the committee chairman who was mandated by the Senate to look into the significance of the Nigerian Peace Corps Bill, delivered a scathing review of the paramilitary group when he laid the findings of his committee before the Senate Tuesday.

“The powers, functions, e.t.c., of the Peace Corps call for concern and this committee would wish that they are subjected to further examination,” Mr. Umaru, APC-Niger East, said.

The senator said the attempts by promoters of the Peace Corps to make government absorb it was strange and starkly different from the approach of its sister organisation in the United States.

“The American Peace Corps, which is used as a model, does not operate as a permanent and pensionable employment as intended in Nigeria under this proposed legislation,” Mr. Umaru said. “Rather, its employment is for a limited period of five years only for regular employees and 24 months for volunteers.”

Yet, Mr. Umaru went on to recommend that the Senate should proceed with passing the harmonised version of the Peace Corps Bill, clearing the way for its onward transfer to the president’s desk for assent.

Dickson Akoh, Peace Corps’ national commandant, said his organisations would offer what the American Peace Corps offers and even more.

The Peace Corps will achieve capacity building for youth creativity and intervention; capacity building for youth development and empowerment in agriculture; and peace education and conflict resolution, Mr. Akoh said.

But a majority of existing government agencies expressed strong opposition to the creation of the organisation.

At a House committee hearing during consideration of the bill, the Office of the Head of Service (HoS) said several government agencies with similar mandates as Peace Corps already exist and listed the Ministry of Youth Development and Ministry of Employment, Labour and Productivity and Ministry of Environment as examples.

Other existing law enforcement agencies include: Ministry of Education, Institute for Peace and Conflict Resolution, National Orientation Agency, National Poverty Eradication Programme and, National Directorate of Employment. The list is far from being exhausted, the head of service said.

Consequently, the HoS urged lawmakers to consider “the implications of the proposed creation of Nigerian Peace Corps on the cost of governance and duplication of duties of existing agencies.”

Law enforcement agencies have taken measures against the Peace Corps since at least 2003 when the State Security Service arrested Mr. Akoh and shut down his offices across the country.

He resumed operation in 2007. But when the SSS clamped down on his organisation again, he launched a civil lawsuit which has dragged since then.

This year alone, the police have detained Mr. Akoh at least twice.

Dickson Akoh, Commandant General of the Peace Corps of Nigeria

At the first incident, armed officers from police, SSS and the Nigerian Army stormed the head office of the Peace Corps and took Mr. Akoh and more than 40 others into custody.

The head office was also shut by the police, and has not been reopened ever since.

Mr. Akoh said he had won at least 11 cases against different security agencies over the past 15 years. The police will neither confirm nor deny this assertion.

While several agencies under executive control have openly expressed opposition to the Peace Corps, President Muhammadu Buhari and Acting President Yemi Osinbajo have not said whether they will assent to the bill or reject it.

Enquiries directed to presidential spokespersons, including Garba Shehu, Laolu Akande and Femi Adesina, went unanswered throughout Thursday.

Senate sources with knowledge about the tactics of the Peace Corps told PREMIUM TIMES the group’s promoters gave millions of naira to some senators.

“Apart from the cash bribes that they offered, they even gave some key lawmakers who worked to ensure that the bill was passed more than 1000 job slots,” a senator said.

But PREMIUM TIMES could not confirm if Mr. Umaru received cash bribes from the Peace Corps.

Promoters of the Peace Corps also put pressure on some lawmakers through their constituents.

“They asked our constituents to inundate us with calls about jobs prospects in the Peace Corps,” the senator said.

Senate spokesperson, Abdullahi Aliyu, did not respond to PREMIUM TIMES request for comments on the allegations.

But Enyinnaya Abaribe, PDP-Abia South, denied receiving any bribes from the Peace Corps.

The “allegation is beneath contempt,” he said.

“None at all,” he said while responding to specific question on whether he received cash bribes.

Mr. Akoh was said to raised funds from the sale of forms to unemployed youth seeking job placement in his organisation. He has been selling employment forms to prospective recruits at N1,500 per copy.

But he told PREMIUM TIMES in January that the N40,000 he collects from prospective members was meant for registration, training, procurement of kits, amongst others.

“The ICPC has investigated us in 2004 and established that we’re not extorting money from the youth,” he added.

Other than the possible employment opportunities that an established Peace Corps could bring to Nigerian youth, there appears to be no other unique reason for its creation.

But even “this can be achieved by strengthening existing agencies and not necessarily creating a new one so as not to overburden the federal government,” Mr. Umaru said.

Yet, the senator declined requests from PREMIUM TIMES seeking to know why he urged his colleagues to allow the Peace Corps Bill scale through in disregard of the findings of his committee.

One more thing to restructure

0

 

By Simon Kolawole

Matthew Syed, the British journalist and author, is one of my favourite sports columnists. His article, ‘Why Chelsea fans are doctoring reality over the latest controversy’ (The Times of London, August 17, 2015), readily comes to mind as I ponder over the nature and quality of public debate in Nigeria. Jose Mourinho, the Chelsea coach at the time, had been in the thick of controversy over the way he treated the team doctor, Eva Carneiro. Mourinho publicly chastised her for going on the field to treat an injured player, Eden Hazard, while the team was desperately searching for a winning goal in the dying minutes of a league match against Swansea.

Syed analysed the pattern of reactions among football fans as the incident snowballed into a crisis. While, as expected, Chelsea fans sought to rationalise Mourinho’s action, fans of other clubs were, unsurprisingly, critical of the Special One. Syed then asserted: “The twist, of course, is that had Arsène Wenger engaged in the same behaviour, Arsenal fans would have been falling over themselves to justify it. Ditto with other clubs and fans.” His take is that “managerial behaviour is judged not by what happened, but on pre-existing allegiances… Chelsea fans know that Mourinho was in the wrong… but they defend him out of a sense of loyalty.”

I have been sitting in my balcony, with popcorn on the one hand and soda on the other, keenly observing the patterns of public debate on President Buhari since he came to power. You would find the debates quite amusing if you are a FIFA-badge spectator like me. There are people who think Buhari can do no wrong. And there are those who think he can do no right. On the other side of the hemisphere, there are those who believe Jonathan has never done anything good in his life, and there are those who insist he has never done anything wrong. In fact, the whole game seems to be Jonathan vs Buhari. The match was decided in 2015 but we are still settling the score.

I don’t really understand why the whole debate has to be about Jonathan and Buhari. Many people have simply refused to move on from 2015. The bitterness of that poll still haunts us like an evil spirit, particularly on social media. No argument is complete without reference to both men. So when one person says “why hasn’t Buhari gone to Dapchi since 110 schoolgirls were kidnapped?” someone will reply with a question: “Did Jonathan visit Chibok?” I have seen same people who condemned Jonathan for not going to Chibok now defending Buhari for avoiding Dapchi. I’ve also seen people who defended Jonathan now condemning Buhari for the same inaction.

Syed says “self-conscious hypocrisy” is an occasional demand of group cohesion. That is, we overrule our senses to go along with the group. Several experiments have proved that we tend to respond to issues not strictly on the basis of the logic of the facts in front of us but based on the biases in our minds. If a governor pulls down the house of his political opponent for tax default, our responses would be shaped by our disposition to him.  If we are sympathetic to him, we would seek to justify it by saying “but that guy should have paid his taxes”. If we are not, we would say: “This is surely political vendetta.” A neutral person would ask: what is the penalty for tax default? Bulldozing?

There is yet another interesting dimension to hypocrisy. Syed, in the same article, recalled a famous experiment by Professor Lee Ross, a psychologist from Stanford University, in the 1990s. Lee took peace proposals prepared by Israeli negotiators, labelled them as “Palestinian proposals”, and asked Israeli citizens to assess them. “The Israelis liked the Palestinian proposal attributed to Israel more than they liked the Israeli proposal attributed to the Palestinians,” Ross said. Logically, Palestinians would automatically dislike a Palestinian-authored proposal attributed to Israel. Both groups would judge proposals not on their merit but according to the identity of who came up with them.

I find the article by Syed so instructive that I must have read it a million times. It has helped me to understand public debate in Nigeria much better, especially the psychology of it. There are issues that I think are so glaring that there should not be much argument on right or wrong. But when you hear people talk, you will be gripped by the fear of God. You support Jonathan so you have to defend him, no matter what. You are Buhari’s fan so you have to behave the part, no matter what. There are people who support or attack blindly because they want to be seen to be right all the time — that their original position was not a mistake. They are always looking for reinforcement.

By the way, I don’t think it is a hidden fact that I am a fan of Buhari. I supported Buhari to be president long before he threw his hat in the ring in 2003. However, I am man enough to admit that things are not turning out well. But to say he has achieved nothing is to go overboard. No single president can transform Nigeria overnight, no matter the grandiose campaign promises. Developmental governance is a relay race, I often theorise. Jonathan did his part and deserves recognition and commendation. Buhari is building on many of Jonathan’s achievements, as seen in railway, agriculture and anti-graft war. Is that too much to admit? Is it not about Nigeria, after all?

One thing that discourages me about public debate in Nigeria is the dominance of duplicity. It easily blinds us. I can give an example straightway. Jonathan went to dance “Azonto” in Kano after the Nyanya bombing in 2014. Four years later, Buhari went for an extravagant wedding in Kano after the Dapchi kidnappings. Jonathan’s aides did not see anything wrong in the Kano rally convened to welcome Mallam Ibrahim Shekarau to PDP while Nigeria was bleeding. In 2018, Buhari’s social media aide said the president was an adult and could decide to go anywhere he liked. Are you getting me? That is group allegiance at work. Nigeria takes the back seat in the reasoning.

I’m running out of space, so I will now rush my argument. First, I surrender to the fact that bias is human and universal. It is not peculiar to Nigerians. I will, also, not dispute the fact that partisanship is always a factor in public debate. We tend to go with group dynamics in advancing our arguments irrespective of the facts. Three, we cannot legislate on people’s emotions. We live in a world of opinions and no matter how annoying we find some people, we have to defend their freedom of expression. However, I am beginning to think public debate needs to be “hijacked” by a third force — I mean critics whose primary loyalty is to the progress of Nigeria, no matter who is in power.

No commentator is perfect. We all wear goggles. But some goggles are darker than the others. I benefit tremendously from reading and listening to the intellectual contributions of those who look at issues more dispassionately, suppressing ethnic, religious and partisan allegiances. But many commentators are not capable of controlling their jaundice. In the Fulani herdsmen impasse, for instance, it is so predictable to know where people, including government officials, will pitch their tents. We make it look like a killing competition. The critical issues of deforestation, insecurity in the land, anarchy and weak law-enforcement are not dominating discourse.

Can any society make progress when their collective reasoning is so narrow and lacking in intellectual rigour? I would think the issue that should bother Nigerians the most is that human lives are being lost unnecessarily and the government owes each and every one of us the duty of providing security and ensuring that justice is done to lawbreakers. I would readily accuse Buhari of being lethargic in the herdsmen affair. He deserves to be thoroughly criticised for that. In fact, there are enough issues on the ground for which he should be properly criticised. I can list a dozen instantly. But why hate a man because of his religion and ethnicity? Why?

We need to examine our collective reasoning. Nigeria can never be better than the collective reasoning of Nigerians. Everybody cannot reason alike, but we can reason together. I understand that elections are around the corner and politicians must politick to remain in office or gain control of power. I know. However, we need to birth a new political mindset that emphasises a common loyalty to the development of Nigeria. We need men and women who, after voting for whoever they like, will continue to insist on good governance — whether or not the winner is their preferred candidate. This group of Nigerians must overwhelm the cults of partisans in the public sphere.

I am aware that those who refuse to be blinded by sectional emotions stand the risk of being accused of “sitting on the fence” or being “naïve”, but then there is always a price to pay for your convictions. You should prefer to be abused for having a bias for national cohesion and development. Our collective thinking, as things stand, is very detrimental to our progress. The wrong people are controlling the airwaves. We cannot be reducing the whole debate about Nigeria to Jonathan vs Buhari. For all you care, Buhari and Jonathan will pass away. Presidents will come and presidents will go. Nigeria will remain. If we are wise then, our priority should always be Nigeria.

AND FOUR OTHER THINGS…

‘FISCAL FEDERALISM’

Lagosians are having a foretaste of “fiscal federalism” as higher taxes have been introduced by the state government. The vehicle licence for a 16-tire trailer will now cost N200,000 — up from N8,750! You could pay a fee as high as N50,000 for sinking a life-saving borehole at home! Land use charge is heading for the skies! But why are advocates of “true federalism” protesting? When oil-producing states begin to keep their petrodollars, taxation is going to be fastest way to make up for the lost revenue in most states (or is it regions) of the “true federation”. It’s not only northern Nigeria that will pay the price, as the spiteful campaigners think. You ain’t seen nothing yet, guys. Reality.

THE MONEY MACHINE

Finally, a senator has revealed what they “earn”. Senator Shehu Sani says every senator gets N13.5 million monthly, which they “account” for (LOL), and another N700,000 they don’t account for. Of course, principal officers collect more. There is also the N200 million for “constituency project”. Long ago, we heard about blackmail money under the pretext of “oversight” function. Failure to play ball will lead to public hearings, probes and resolutions. There is also “prepaid” budget padding — under which MDAs pay “cash down” to have their budgets handsomely inflated. Many lawmakers even nominate contractors or do contracts. We are a bunch of jokers in this country. Disgusting.

AJAOKUTA STEALTH

I was fascinated by the recent “public hearing” on Ajaokuta Steel Company. Ms Natasha Akpoti, a lawyer, made a depressing presentation on the history of the project. But she missed it when she said it should not be privatised. She didn’t name a single company that is well run by government. We that can’t run refineries will run a steel mill? Are you joking me? She made me laugh when she said foreigners should not run the mill because it can produce guns. She probably doesn’t know Nigeria actually imports arms from foreigners! As it has now turned out, the lawmakers, in fact, approved N2bn for the concessioning and are now opposing it after “public hearing”. Nigeria!!!

PEACED OFF

The National Assembly is hell-bent on turning a private security outfit, called Peace Corps, into a government agency. At this rate, the lawmakers will soon upgrade Arksego and KingsGuard to parastatals. President Buhari did the right thing by withholding assent to the bill. If Nigeria is under-policed, the logical thing to do is strengthen the police force — both in numbers and with modern systems that reduce the physical presence of police everywhere. But to create yet another body, after NSCDC, and keep bloating the huge public service is not what we need now. Whenever we have a challenge in Nigeria, we always think the solution is a new law or new agency. Warped.

There’re a lot of unanswered questions on Dapchi abduction, says Hadiza Usman

Hadiza Usman, Managing Director of the Nigerian Ports Authority (NPA), says many questions need to be answered in relation to the recent abduction of 110 school girls from Dapchi Yobe State, stressing that no school in the North East should be left without security.

Usman is a co-founder of the Bring Back our Girls (BBOG) campaign group and participated in the groups daily sit-outs at the unity fountain in Abuja until her appointment into the NPA.

She described the Dapchi abduction as a very sad development that sets the nation miles back in the counter-insurgency operation.

“You know, we have seen (some of the Chibok) girls being returned, girls being rescued, and attendant reduction in the activities of Boko Haram. But this abduction has set us back and there are things that we need to ask,” Usman told Premium Times during an interview.

“There are questions that need to be answered. For example, how can you have a boarding, lets not even say that it is a girls’ school, how do you have a school not being protected as it should? Even if it is a day school. How do you have a boarding school, girls boarding school, not being protected as it should?

“So, there are many questions that we need to ask. Having experienced what we did with the Chibok girls, we cannot now have a similar situation existing in the same environment -the school is not secured, no military deployed in that situation, I think a committee has been set up so we look forward to what it is they are going to tell us.

“I would say this is a huge step back and it questions quite a lot of things that we should have put in place to prevent a recurrence. You cannot have our schools unprotected. You cannot have boarding schools unprotected in the north east as these are soft targets.”

However, Usman noted that the Federal Government did not try to deny that some girls ere abducted, unlike the Goodluck Jonathan administration that at first refused to accept the Chibok kidnap and the seriousness of the insurgency.

“One of the issues around Chibok girls and the abduction in 2014/15 is to do with the seeming denial of the government of accepting that an abduction has happened. Seeming denial of the extent of the insurgency,” she said.

“So to the extent that now you see there is recognition and acceptance that yes people were abducted, recognition and acceptance that yes, we need to work on rescuing these girls, work on the abduction status and also investigate how it could happen, having claimed that we have made significant milestone in achieving reduction in insurgency.”

The accessible billionaire’s legacy

 

In post–World War II America, when John D. MacArthur earned his millions, he was the least known of the nation’s wealthiest men. Even after he earned his great wealth in insurance and real estate, MacArthur lived in relative simplicity with Catherine at a Florida hotel he owned, and he often boasted that he did not know his own financial worth. When he died in 1978, he left over $1 billion in assets to the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation.

John MacArthur rose from humble means to become one of the richest men in America. Born on March 6, 1897, in Pennsylvania, he was the son of an itinerant Baptist preacher and missionary. The family never had much and moved frequently because of the father’s work. By the time John was 16, he had left school and moved to Chicago where he worked with an older brother in the insurance industry. This career move paid off. At just 19, John sold more than $1 million in insurance in one year.

In 1928, MacArthur purchased his first insurance company, Marquette Life, at 140 South Dearborn Street, in the same Marquette Building where the Foundation is now headquartered. A decade later, he bought Bankers Life and Casualty Company, which quickly became the centerpiece of his emerging business empire. The company succeeded because of his simple, but revolutionary, idea: door-to-door salesmen were replaced with mass marketing techniques to keep down cost and make coverage affordable for the “everyday man.” By 1956, Bankers Life was the largest health and life insurance company in the United States.

John met Chicago-native Catherine Hyland at his brother’s insurance company where she worked as a secretary. Catherine, one of five children, was raised on the South Side by Irish immigrant parents. John was the public face of their business ventures, while Catherine often worked behind the scenes, tracking details and accounts. He always acknowledged Catherine’s role in his business success. “She helped build it up,” he said of her when drawing up the paperwork to create the Foundation.

After building their fortune together and making a home in Chicago, the couple moved to Florida in 1958. There, the MacArthurs began to accumulate their vast real estate holdings. By the time John died, he had purchased more than 100,000 acres of Florida land. He also bought the Colonnades Hotel on the south end of Singer Island; located on a breathtaking stretch of beach, it became the couple’s home. A table in the Colonnades coffee shop served as his office. Indeed, he was often mistaken for the hotel handyman. Media called him “the accessible billionaire.”

Despite a frugal lifestyle, the MacArthurs quietly donated to worthy causes, including the North Palm Beach YMCA and Palm Beach Atlantic University. They made the ballroom at the Colonnades available free of charge for charitable causes.

John’s longtime friend and attorney William Kirby convinced him that a foundation would allow his money to go to good use long after he was gone. On October 18, 1970, the documents for the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation were completed. John intentionally left the business of what to fund to the Foundation’s first board of directors, which included Catherine; Kirby; his son, Roderick; radio commentator Paul Harvey, a friend from Chicago whose popular program carried ads for Bankers Life; and Louis Feil, a business associate from New York. “I made the money; you guys will have to figure out what to do with it,” MacArthur told the board. This direction presented the Foundation’s first board with two challenges: how to divest responsibly the assets and how to shape a forward-looking organization that could change with society’s evolving challenges.

When John died of cancer on January 6, 1978, the Foundation assumed his assets, estimated at $1 billion. In less than a year, the board began to award grants. Early grant recipients included Amnesty International and the John D. MacArthur Beach State Park. In the 40 years since John’s death, the Foundation he and Catherine created has awarded more than $6.8 billion to nearly 10,000 organizations and individuals in 116 countries and all 50 U.S. states, as well as Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands.

This article is culled from MacArthur Foundation

Presidential aspirant Omoyele Sowore planning to defeat Buhari with ‘$200 each from 100,000 Nigerians’

 

Omoyele Sowore, Publisher of the whistle-blowing newspaper, Sahara Reporters, says he is running for Nigeria’s number one office in order to change the purposeless leadership that has come to define the country’s politics.

To realise his ambition of defeating President Muhammadu Buhari in 2019, Sowore is banking on a contribution of “$200 per person from 100,000 Nigerians”.

He said the Buhari administration has recorded zero achievement on the core areas of his campaign, namely: anti-corruption, anti-terrorism and economic stabilisation.

“Buhari’s appeal was supposed to be a tough stance against corruption and an ability to address the security crises posed by Boko Haram,” Sowore said during an interview with Premium Times.

“No single major victory has been notched in the anti-corruption fight. Boko Haram is still alive and kicking. And the President’s inaction and lack of leadership is causing the herdsmen-farmers conflicts to take on an even more dangerous dimension. The Nigerian state is in a shambles.”

Elections in Nigeria cost a lot of money, but Sowore is confident of raising the required funds.

“We will be sourcing funds directly from the Nigerian people. Nigerians have demonstrated a capacity to devote their resources to projects that they believe in,” he said.

“The recent team that represented Nigeria in bobsledding at the Winter Olympics raised almost $200,000 – a lot of it from Nigerians. We are already seeing and receiving commitments for support.

“Our approach will revolutionize the way politics is funded in Nigeria. There is also a lot of support that is coming in the form of goodwill donations.

“We also have something that counts for a lot – an army of technology savvy supporters and media platforms that will amplify our voice to the Nigerian people.

“Barack Obama raised millions of dollars from Nigerians in the US alone in 2008/2009 and subsequently after.

“100,000 Nigerians contributing $200 per person can help fund a clean election devoid of dirty money. With that, we can win the Presidency and bring them back a lot of change!”

Sowore, who is currently based in the United States of America, said he is already doing underground mobilization and advocacy in and outside Nigeria.

“The efforts to mobilize progressives and to form a coalition of progressive parties and organizations is underway. I am using my time in the U.S. to mobilize diaspora Nigerians,” he said.

“This weekend, for instance, I will be holding a town hall in Maryland with Nigerians. I am also spending a great deal of my time meeting with my strategy and policy teams – members of whom include some really accomplished Nigerians.

“Unknown to many I have been on the ground Nigeria in the last two months.The work goes on. I will certainly be spending more time on the ground in Nigeria.”

Nigeria’s population is made up of majorly young people and it is obvious that the 2019 general election will be won by the candidate h appeals most to the youth.

“If there is anything we have learned in the last few years, it is the fact that the Nigerian electorate has become impatient with purposeless leadership. My candidacy is generating significant interest across Nigeria, especially amongst the youth. The youth demographic is the largest single voting block,” Sowore said.

Buhari-Senate showdown: ICPC gets two acting chairmen in six months

 

Bako Abdullahi, Acting Chairman of the Independent Corrupt Practices and other Related Offences Commission (ICPC) has handed over to Musa Usman Abubakar, Secretary of the commission, as the Senate delays the confirmation of President Muhammadu Buhari’s nominee.

The Senate had vowed not to confirm any appointment by Buhari until the President removes Ibrahim Magu as Acting Chairman of Economic Financial Crime Commission (EFCC).

The Senate rejected the nomination of Magu twice but Buhari has refused to replace him.

The stalemate between the executive and the senate has affected the ICPC, with Bolaji Owasanoye, a Professor of Law who was nominated Chairman, still awaiting confirmation from the Senate since August 2017.

In a statement on Thursday, Rasheedat Okoduwa, spokesperson of the commission, said the Secretary of the commission would now act as Chairman until Owasanoye’s appointment is confirmed by the Senate.

“In a brief ceremony, which was witnessed by the heads of departments and other senior management staff, the former acting Chairman of the Commission and two-term board member, Alh. Bako Abdullahi, said he was handing over to the Secretary as his tenure as a member had come to an end,” the statement said.

Abdullahi took over from the former Chairman, Ekpo Nta in September last year.

He commended the management and staff of the commission for supporting him, and urged them to extend the same level of support to the new Secretary.

The former Acting Chairman advised ICPC staff to intensify efforts in eradicating corruption in Nigeria.

He challenged the staff not to let the recent Transparency International’s rating of the country dampen their enthusiasm, rather to see it as a shot in the arm for a renewed drive by the commission to combat the evil that corruption represents.

In his response after receiving the handover documents, the Secretary praised Abdullahi  for running a strategic organisation like ICPC.

He solicited the cooperation of staff to succeed in carrying the heavy burden being placed on his shoulders, and promised to put in his best in order to make the Commission better in all ramifications.

Court rules Synagogue church has a case to answer over 2014 building collapse

 

 A Lagos State High Court has dismissed the “no-case submission” filed by the Synagogue Church of All Nations (SCOAN) in the case brought against it by the Lagos State government following a building collapse in the church premises in September 2014.

The collapse of the six-storeyed building still under construction led to the death of 116 people, most of them South African.

The Lagos State Directorate of Public Prosecutions said that the church had gone ahead with the construction in spite of disapproval by the state’s Urban and Regional Planning Agency.

Consequently, the state government sued Hardrock Construction & Engineering Company and Jandy Trust Ltd, the companies handling the construction, as well as Oladele Ogundeji and Akinbela Fatiregun, owners of the companies.

They were charged with violating Section 75 of the Urban and Regional Planning Law of Lagos State 2010 and Section 222 of the Criminal Law of Lagos State 2011.

Also, a coroner’s inquest set up to independently investigate the incident recommended that SCOAN should be prosecuted for failing to obtain necessary approval before embarking on the construction of the building, and that the two structural engineers be prosecuted for criminal negligence.

The defendants were arraigned on April 19, 2016, and they pleaded ‘not guilty.’

After tendering several documents and calling several witnesses to prove the allegations against the accused persons, the Lagos State Government closed its case in October 2017.

However, the defendants, rather than open their defence, filed a ‘no-case’ submission, arguing that the prosecution had failed to establish a prima facie case against them; hence the court should discharge them.

When hearing resumed on Thursday, Justice Lateef Lawal-Akapo dismissed the no-case submission filed by the defendants and held that a prima facie case had been established and that they have a case to answer.

He subsequently adjourned the case to April 27 for the defendants to open their case.