Home Blog Page 1950

Lekki Shootings: Amnesty International says it has credible evidence soldiers killed protesters

AMNESTY International, human rights advocacy group says it has received ‘credible but disturbing evidence’ that security forces of the government killed peaceful protesters at Lekki Toll Gate area of Lagos on October 20. 

“The Nigerian authorities’ must end their attempts to cover up the Lekki Toll Gate massacre, Amnesty International said, as it released a new timeline investigating the atrocity one week later,” Amnesty International said in a new investigative timeline released on Wednesday.

“The timeline – available here – collates photographs and video footage to confirm that Nigerian Army vehicles left Bonny Camp, a military base approximately a seven-minute drive from the toll gate, at 6.29 pm local time on 20 October.”

Footage then tracks the vehicles to the toll gate. At approximately 6.45pm, the Nigerian military opened fire on the #EndSars protesters who were peacefully calling for an end to police brutality.

Osai Ojigho, Country Director of Amnesty International said, “What happened at Lekki Toll Gate has all the traits of the Nigerian authorities’ pattern of a cover-up whenever their defence and security forces commit unlawful killings.”

“One week on, the Nigerian authorities still have many questions to answer: who ordered the use of lethal force on peaceful protesters? Why were CCTV cameras on the scene dismantled in advance? And who ordered electricity being turned off minutes before the military opened fire on protesters?

Ojigho said the initial denials of the involvement of soldiers in the shooting was followed by the shameful denial of the loss of lives as a result of the military’s attack against the protests.

According to her, many people are still missing since the day of the incident, adding that credible evidence shows that the military prevented ambulances from reaching the severely injured in the aftermath.

Amnesty International, she said is again calling on Nigerian authorities to bring to justice those behind the shooting and to protect those who are exercising their right to freedom of assembly.

The organization is still investigating the shooting, and the reported removal of bodies of those killed by the military in an attempt to remove evidence, Ojigho said.

Tracking the military’s movements

Amnesty International’s Crisis Response experts investigated and verified social media videos and photographs that confirm the Nigerian security forces were present at the Lekki Toll Gate when the shootings occurred.

At 6.29pm local time in Lagos, two military vehicles were filmed leaving Bonny Camp on videos shared on social media. Later footage shows four vehicles with flashing lights in a convoy, and they appear to be vehicles used by the Nigerian military and police.

The same vehicles head east along Ozumba Mbadiwe Avenue – which changes its name to the Lekki-Epe Expressway – in the direction of the Lekki Toll Gate. On this route, the vehicles pass several international embassies and consulates, including the Japanese Embassy and the Australian High Commission.

Further photographs and footage capture the vehicles arriving at the toll gate, before the peaceful protest is disrupted by men in military uniform and gunfire is heard. As night time descended, protesters continued to film and share videos of the shootings. Later in the evening, videos of the victims were also shared on social media.

Amnesty International said it has been monitoring developments across Nigeria since the #EndSars protest began on 8 October 2020.

Nigerians have been taking to the streets, peacefully demanding an end to police brutality, extrajudicial executions and extortion by the Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS), a unit of the Nigerian police tasked with fighting violent crimes.

At least 56 people have died across the country since protests began. In multiple cases, the security forces have used excessive force in an attempt to control or stop the protests.

On its Twitter handle on Wednesday, the “Amnesty International said has received credible but disturbing evidence of excessive use of force occasioning deaths of protesters at Lekki toll gate in Lagos.

“While we continue to investigate the killings, Amnesty International wishes to remind the authorities that under international law, security forces may only resort to the use of lethal force when strictly unavoidable to protect against an imminent threat of death or serious injury,” the group shared on its Twitter page.

#ENDSARS: Oyo State sets up N500m compensation fund for victims of injustice

THE Oyo State government has set up a 500 million naira compensation fund for the victims of police brutality in the state.

This was revealed yesterday at a stakeholder meeting by Seyi Makinde, the state governor in Ibadan,  the capital city.

“Let me also state that we have set up an initial Five Hundred Million Naira Compensation Fund for victims of injustice,” he said.

Makinde encouraged residents of the state that have suffered any form of injustice from the police in the past and in the course of #ENDSARS protest to seize all available and legitimate platforms provided by the state to lodge their complaints.

“I encourage everyone who has suffered any form of injustice in the past or as a result of the End SARS protests to please take advantage of the platforms we have provided to log their cases. We have an email service and a direct reporting portal on the Oyo State Government website. A judicial panel for Oyo State will be inaugurated in the next one week to look into cases of injustice.”

In addition, the state has equally set up a 500 Million Naira MSME fund to be disbursed to youths with entrepreneurial skills in order to cushion the economic consequences occasioned by the outbreak of COVID-19 in the state. 

“We know that the protests have been a result of simmering anger among the youths. We are aware of the economic situation, especially the reduced income of many due to the COVID-19 pandemic and also the general unemployment situation in the country. Let me reassure you that we will continue to prioritise actions that will positively impact the youths.

“For this reason, we have taken the following immediate actions to address some of the issues raised by the youths during the protest:

“I have directed that a 500 Million Naira MSME fund be set up. This fund will be disbursed to youths who have bright entrepreneurial ideas that will provide further employment and improve the economic landscape in Oyo State.”

The governor has also directed the employment of 5,000 young persons across all government agency schemes over the next few months. The criteria for employment and the dates for assessment will be announced by the agency authorities.

“Going forward, starting from 2021, there will be provisions made for the Direct Labour Agency in the budget. This will ensure more employment opportunities for residents who have requisite skills when projects are awarded,” he added.

While stating that his administration will continue to protect the rights of citizens of the state, the governor assured the people that his administration will continue to live up to its campaign promises. 

“Let me again reassure the good people of Oyo State that our administration will continue to live up to our mantra of putting the people first. We will continue to protect the rights of every resident of Oyo State as contained in the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 as amended. Also, let me state that we have not changed our open-door policy. We are always happy to dialogue with everyone for the economic good and development of our beloved state,” he said.

Is Buhari’s daughter a board member of NNPC?

“BUHARI’S daughter is a board member of NNPC,” a social media user @tesseract_ claimed on Monday, October 19, 2020.

“Her salary is N6.7 million, you get N30, 000 monthly for N-Power and you are telling me Buhari shouldn’t resign” reads part of the tweet which also have the EndSARS hashtag.

The hashtag, End Special Anti-Robbery Squad (#EndSARS) or  is a decentralised social movement against police brutality and bad governance in Nigeria.

Muahammadu Buhari is the President of Nigeria.

N-Power is a social investment scheme which pays enrolled youth a monthly stipend of N30,000.

The claim has been retweeted by over 30, 000 people, quoted 720 times and garnered more than 24, 000 likes.

The claim that Buhari’s daughter is a board member of the NNPC.

THE CLAIM:

That Buhari’s daughter is a board member of Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC).

THE FINDINGS:

The claim did not state which of the Buhari’s daughters  is being referred too. However, a picture of Zahra Buhari was added to the thread. In addition to a contradictory screenshots which state that she is a deputy manager at the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation, NNPC.

The NNPC is the state-owned oil corporation which asides its exploration activities, has powers and operational interests in refining, petrochemicals and products transportation as well as marketing.

A check on the official website of the NNPC shows a list of a 10-member board of the corporation which does not include Zahra Buhari or any of his known daughters.

They are: Chief Timipre Sylva, the Minister of State for Petroleum Resources, Mele Kyari, Group Managing Director of the NNPC, Dr Stephen Dike, member of the NNPC board and Chief Pius Akinyelure also a member.

Other members are Sen. Magnus Abe, Dr Tajuddeen Umar, Mallam Mohammed Lawal, Mrs Lami Onayi Ahmed, Dr Mahmoud Isa Dutse and Mrs Hadiza Coomassie who is the Secretary to the Corporation and Legal Adviser.

Screenshot of NNPC board members from it website.

More so, on June 24, 2020, the Federal Ministry of Information and Culture (FMIC) published a press statement announcing the list of the board members approved by the president.

The statement was signed by  Mrs Enefaa Bob-manuel, a Deputy Director (Information) in the Federal Ministry of Petroleum Resources.

“The members of the NNPC Board who had on 2nd June, 2020 been approved by President Mohammadu Buhari are the Hon. Minister of State for Petroleum Resources, Timipre Sylva who doubles as the Alternate Chairman of the Board, Mallam Mele Kolo Kyari, GMD of NNPC, Senator Magnus Abe, Dr Isah Dutse, Permanent Secretary Ministry of Finance, Dr Tajudeen Umaru, Dr Steven Dike, Mrs Lami Ahmed, Chief Pius Akinyelure, Malam Mohammed Lawal and Secretary of the Board, Mrs Hadiza Commassie,” the statement reads in part.

The claim that Buhari’s daughter is a board member of the NNPC.

Prior to that, the list of the board members was earlier released by the Presidency on May 30.

In addition, the list of the previous set of board members during leadership of the late Group Managing Director, Dr Maikanti Baru did not have Buhari’s daughter’s name either.

THE VERDICT:

Available evidence does not support the claim that Buhari’s daughter is a board member at NNPC. The claim is FALSE.

This report was originally published by FactCheckHub

#ENDSARS: We were requested to restore normalcy by Lagos Govt – Nigerian Army

THE 81 Division of the Nigerian Army, Lagos says there was no time its personnel shot protesters in the state stating that its involvement was based on a request by the Lagos State Government after a 24-hour curfew was imposed in the state.

The Army in the statement titled ‘Press release on alleged massacre of protesters at Lekki toll gate’, signed by Osoba Olaniyi, a Major and the acting Deputy Director, 81 Division Army Public Relations,  in reaction to the public outcry that followed the Lekki shooting said the decision to call in the military was taken by the Lagos State Government after a 24 hours’ curfew was imposed.

It further stated that claims that soldiers shot at #EndSARS protesters were untrue, unfounded and aimed at causing anarchy in the country, adding that soldiers acted within the confines of the Rules of Engagement for Internal Security operations.

“The attention of Headquarters 81 Division Nigerian Army has been drawn to a viral video on social media in which it was alleged that civilians protesters were massacred by soldiers at Lekki toll plaza,” Olaniyi said.

“This allegation is untrue, unfounded and aimed at causing anarchy in the country. At no time did soldiers of the Nigerian Army open fire on any civilian.”

He argued that from the onset of the ENDSARS protest, there was no time personnel of 81 Division Nigerian Army Lagos, were involved.

“However, the decision to call in the military was taken by the Lagos State Government after a 24 hours curfew was imposed.”

Olaniyi added that the request to the Army to restore normalcy was “as a result of the violence which led to several police stations being burnt, policemen killed, suspects in police custody released and weapons carted away.”

“The situation was fast degenerating into anarchy. It was at this point that LASG requested for the military to intervene in order to restore normalcy.”

“The intervention of the military followed all laid down procedures for internal security operations and all the soldiers involved acted within the confines of the Rules of Engagement for Internal Security operations.”

“The 81 Division reiterated that its men never shot at civilians while discharging their duties, noting that there were “glaring and convincing evidence to attest to this fact.”

The ENDSAR protests in some parts of the country turned violent after soldiers allegedly shot at peaceful #EndSARS protesters at the Lekki toll gate on Tuesday, October 20.

The Lekki toll gate had been one of the rallying points for protesters in Lagos State.

Nigerians had gone to the street demanding an end to Police brutality and also called for the scrapping of the Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS), a notorious Police unit accused of extrajudicial killings, extortions and torture.

File Photo: Gen. Tukur Yusuf Buratai, Nigeria’s Chief of Army Staff.

The Army statement is coming one week after several calls from within and outside the country for a thorough investigation into what happened at the Lekki Tollgate.

Amnesty International, the human rights advocacy group,  has said that at least 12 people were killed on Tuesday at both Alausa and Lekki toll gate, while Babajide Sanwo-Olu,  Governor of Lagos State, has continued to insist on two death from the shooting.

But the Army in the face of multiple evidence had continued to deny and insisted that it was not present at Lekki during the shooting, stating that the reports were fake.

A Forensic analysis report published by the Digital Forensic Research (DRF) Lab on Thursday of videos showing the shooting of protesters at the Lekki toll-gate area by soldiers on October 20 has shown them to be genuine.

Obianuju Catherine Udeh, a Nigerian Disc Jockey, professionally known as DJ Switch who had in an Instagram live video recounted her experience during the shooting, confirmed soldiers presence and further stating that at least 15 people were killed in the shootings and

She also said she and other survivors took the victims’ bodies to the soldiers who took them away.

 

#EndSARS: CSOs condemn violence, demand transparent prosecution of erring police officers

A Coalition of Civil Societies Organisations (CSOs), has condemned the acts of thuggery, vandalism, hate speeches, fake news and the attacks on security personnel and security facilities by some hoodlums that followed the #ENDSARS protest across the country. 

“As we continue to condemn the use of ‘live bullets’ on unarmed protesters at the Lekki Toll Gate, on October 20, 2020, we also join our voices to condemn acts of thuggery, hate speeches, and fake news,” said the coalition, in a joint statement obtained by The ICIR .

“We particularly condemn the hoodlums that attacked security facilities and personnel of the Nigeria Police Force as two wrongs never make a right.”

The group said  that the Federal Government must expedite speedy and transparent prosecution of officers of the disbanded Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS) indicted for extra-judicial killings and human rights abuses in the country in order to build public trust.

“We still maintain that the 5-for-5 demand by the #EndSARS movement should be urgently met in the interest of the Nigerian state.”

“One of the demands is the transparent prosecution of the officers responsible for the brutality against citizens. In order to build trust in government, we immediately request the prosecution of the defunct Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS) officers who have been identified in the killings, torture, and rapes of citizens.”

It also commended the request of the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) to Abubakar Malami, the Minister of Justice and the Attorney-General of the Federation, to ensure speedy prosecution of 35 operatives of the defunct SARS.

“These officers were accused of human rights violations and abuse of office in a report by the presidential investigation panel.”

The organisations, which called on President Muhammadu Buhari to constitute the governing council of the NHRC, said they have already started tracking court cases and proceedings against officers of the disbanded unit of the Nigerian Police Force.

“As a Civil Society Collective, we have begun tracking initiated court cases, particularly in Lagos and Ogun, this in addition to the panels of inquiry/restitution set up by the states; so far we are reviewing the 27 of the 36 states that already announced these measures.

We have also begun to document shreds of evidence with a view to track and underscore the various human rights abuses, following the End SARS protests; this includes the launch of the Missing Persons Portal and tracking of cases specific to violence against women. In addition, we are ready to provide live streaming and tech support to the Panel setup, in order to enhance the credibility of the investigative process.”

The coalition expressed displeasure over attacks on public and private properties by hoodlums especially in search of warehouses, and the looting of COVID-19 palliatives, which were supplied by the Coalition Against COVID-19 (CA-COVID).

“We have watched with disdain the impunity, and outrightly denounce the assault on public and private properties by hoodlums. The attack in many states of the federation on warehouses, and the looting of COVID-19 palliatives, which were supplied by the Coalition Against COVID-19 (CA-COVID), has thrown up another worrying dimension and exposes the rot and corruption in our governance system.

“We unequivocally condemn these attacks and call on the Governors’ Forum to tell Nigerians why they (Governors) intentionally hoarded food items supplied in good faith by the Coalition. We have read various official statements from some of the state governments and an unofficial statement attributed to the CA-COVID. Some of the statements raise some credibility questions.”

The CSOs includes Centre for Democracy and Development (CDD), Enough is Enough (EIE), Partners for Electoral Reform, Civil Society Legislative Advocacy Centre (CISLAC), Centre for Information, Technology and Development (CITAD), Yiaga Africa, Global Rights, Project Alert, Women Advocates Research and Documentation Centre (WARDC), Paradigm Initiative (PIN), Rule of Law and Accountability Centre (RULAAC) and HEDA Resource Centre.

Others are African Centre for Media & Information Literacy (AFRICMIL), Community Life Project (CLP), Protest to Power, Social Action, Right to Know, Lawyers Alert, International Press Centre (IPC), Private and Public Development Centre, South Saharan Social Development Organisation, Partners West Africa- Nigeria, Centre LSD, Connected Development (CODE), Stakeholders Development Network (SDN), BUDGiT, CWCW Africa, Peering Advocacy and Advancement Centre in Africa (PAACA), Invictus Africa, Alliance for Credible Election (ACE), Prisoners’ Rehabilitation and Welfare Action (PRAWA), Resource Centre for Human Rights (CHRICED) and Reboot Design.

Why ASUU has not called off its strike -Ogunyemi

BIODUN Ogunyemi, President of the Academic Staff Union of Universities (ASUU) says the union is waiting for the Federal Government to conduct an integrity test on the alternative platform, University Transparency and Accountability Solution (UTAS), before it calls off its ongoing strike.

The UTAS is the payment platform created by ASUU in place of the government’s Integrated Payroll and Personnel Information System (IPPIS).

According to  The Punch, Ogunyemi said the government needed to give clearance to the National Information Technology Development Agency (NITDA), to conduct an integrity test on the software before its final approval.

“The integrity test will be handled by NITDA, it is the government that will facilitate it because NITDA is a government agency and unless you get clearance from the government that test cannot be conducted,” he said.

The ASUU President who noted that the Federal Government has accepted the union’s UTAS in principle added that the leadership of the union would be meeting with the delegation of the government for further discussion. 

“We are still talking, we have given them the position of our members, we are thinking we should be able to hold a meeting this week if they have not changed plans. The meeting for Monday was postponed,” he said.

“In principle, they have accepted UTAS and told us to go for the test, and on our part, we have started the process. We had presented UTAS at three levels, starting with the Ministry of Education, Senate President and members of his team, officials of Ministry of Finance and Office of the Accountant General of the Federation, where all other stakeholders were present, including NITDA, all stakeholders have witnessed the presentation and the next stage of integrity test is what we are moving in to.

“If the government facilitates it, it is not something that should drag for too long at all. We don’t foresee any problem with UTAS; it also depends on how early the government makes it possible for the integrity test to be conducted.”

While stating that members of the union are ready to go back to classes, Ogunyemi added that the union wants sincerity and commitment from the government.

“Our members are ready to resume work as early as the government is ready to play its part. I’m sure you are not suggesting that our members should resume an empty stomach or the strike should be suspended without any concrete action on the side of the government,” he said.

“We don’t like to stay away from our work because we like our students, they are also our children.”

“As far as we are concerned, we don’t have an issue with going back to work, but we want more sincerity on the side of the government. We have not seen enough reasons to believe that they don’t mean what they are telling us but as soon as we see any sign to that effect. we will tell Nigerians.”

SARS detained me for 48 days, victim narrates ordeal to Lagos panel of inquiry

0

OKOLI Agwu Abunike, a resident of Okokomaiko and father of five has narrated to the Judicial Panel of Inquiry and Restitution for victims of SARS-related abuses in Lagos State that he was detained for 48 days by two officers of the Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS).

Babajide Sanwo-Olu, the Lagos State governor had on October 19 inaugurated an 8-man Judicial Panel of Inquiry and Restitution to receive and investigate complaints of police brutality in Lagos.

While having the first sitting on Tuesday, four cases of police brutality were mentioned before the panel led by retired Justice Doris Okuwobi but only that of Abunike was heard by the panel.

Abunike in the first hearing with petition number LASG/JPI/01/2020 said Inspector Sunday and ASP Haruna allegedly arrested him, detained and tortured him on the orders of his boss who had accused him of fraud.

He further said the SARS did not only detained him for 48 days but also sold his properties, thereby making him impoverished and dehumanized, adding that he now runs all kinds of errands in order to feed his family.

“I worked for a company for four and a half years as a manager. After my resignation, my boss invited me for the authentication of my resignation. When I got there, my boss had me arrested by police officers from Ojo police station.

“I was later taken to Ikeja police command where I was manhandled and brutalized by Inspector Sunday popularly known as Baba Ijapa and ASP Haruna. I was labeled a fraudster and was beaten, severely injured, dehumanized and dragged all around Alaba International Market. I was also taken to my church and disgraced before the congregation for an offence I knew nothing about,”  says Abunike.

The father of five said the SARS who were acting on the instruction of his boss detained him, seized his house, sold his car and even refused to yield to the court ruling that asked them to pay him N10 million.

“I was detained for 48 days and a bucket filled with cement was strapped at my back. I had bruise all over my body and two of my teeth were removed. The officers beat my wife and mother and they threatened to kill me if I did not confess to embezzling my company’s fund.

“They took all my property. They seized my house and sold my car to make up for the money they said I had embezzled. My boss also threatened to kill me if I did not pay back all the money I stole. The case was taken before Hon Justice Ibrahim Buba of the Federal High Court and he awarded a damage of N10m against the police. But between 2016 and 2020, I have not seen anything. They have not complied with the judgment.

“They sold my land and car. In fact, the person the land was sold to dragged me before a Magistrate Court in Badagry and the Magistrate remanded me in Kpotopiri prison for three days for my inability to meet up with N50,000 fine.

Abunike, however, appealed to the Lagos panel to compel the SARS to honour the court judgment and return all his properties to him.

“ I want to appeal to this honourable panel to compel the police to honour the judgment of the court and return all my property or pay the damage because I have lost everything that I now live in running errands for people to feed my family.”

Moyo Onigbanjo , Lagos State Attorney General, who was at the inquiry panel to observe the inaugural sitting assured the panel and people of Lagos of the full cooperation of the state government.

“I want to assure the panel of the full cooperation of the Lagos State government. I also want to appeal for the cooperation of the police, victims and Lagosians. All hands must be on deck to unravel the circumstances behind the happenings in the state in the past weeks. We will leave no stone unturned to ensure that justice is served to victims of police and SARS brutality and at the end of the day, whatever decision the panel takes will be in the interest of justice,” says Onigbanjo.

Other cases mentioned include LASG/JPI/02/2020 by Ndukwue Ekekwue who had his spinal cord broken by a SARS operative. His case was adjourned to November 3 while petition number LASG/JPI/03/2020 by Olukoya Ogungbeje and LASG/JPI/05/2020 by Bassey Ejigua were adjourned to November 6, 2020.

Following the absence of petitioners at the inaugural hearing of the panel, Doris Okuwobi, however, adjourned the sitting to Friday, October 30.

Picture claiming Queen Elizabeth wrote a condolence letter to Nigeria over Buhari’s death resurfaces, but it’s fake

Claim

The Queen of the United Kingdom, Her Royal Majesty, Elizabeth II wrote a condolence letter to the Nigerian government over the death of President Muhamadu Buhari.

Verdict

The claim that the Queen wrote a condolence letter is FALSE

FULL TEXT

THREE pictures- claiming evidence of Muhammadu Buhari’s death and that the Queen of Britain, Her Royal Majesty, Queen Elizabeth II, wrote a condolence letter to the Nigerian government over the demise of the president have recently been making rounds on social media and Whatsapp.

An attached post to the pictures claimed that the royal majesty wrote the letter on February 7th, 2017, furthering that former Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, Theresa May, also paid a condolence visit to the Nigerian Ambassador to the UK to register her grief towards the death of the president. 

The text inscribed in one of the pictures reads thus: “The Queen of Britain, Her Royal Majesty Queen Elizabeth II has sent a message of condolence to the family of Nigeria’s President Muhammadu Buhari and the people of Nigeria.” 

There are no official reports on the speculated death of the President and the message of condolence from two sources close to the presidency and to Nigeria have said  President Buhari has passed on and that the photos circulating online are those from his previous visit.

Another London source says Prime Minister Theresa May has visited the Nigerian Ambassador to the UK.

In a message of condolence, the Queen  has said the following about Buhari:

 “The death of President Buhari came to us as a shock. He has been one of the active pillars in Africa. May the good people of Nigeria and Africa know that our hearts are with them in these hard times.” 

Verification

In mid-2016, President Muhammadu Buhari left Nigeria in a highly controversial trip to the United kingdom to treat a ‘persistent’ ear infection not less than a year after he won the 2015 presidential election. The trip, which was to take 10 days, was to enable the President to meet with an “Ear, Nose and Throat” specialist after he was examined by his personal physician and an ENT specialist in Abuja.

The medical leave was, however, extended following concerns his health might get worse. An official statement advanced the leave was extended to enable the president to wait for the results of a series of tests that were carried out on him.

Mr Buhari ended up using seven weeks which fuelled anxiety among Nigerians who were spreading speculations about his health. Upon his return to the country, the president told newsmen he had never felt “so sick” as he felt during his stay in London for treatment.

So, who is behind the picture?

The ICIR ran a  check on one of the pictures which the poster claimed was the Queen’s condolence message, using Google reverse image tool to ascertain the time the image first appeared online. 

The search, which showed seven results in 0.42 seconds, revealed that the earliest use of the image found by The ICIR was on November 18, 2018, in a post titled “Buhari’s cousin Mallam Daura attacks Nnamdi Kanu for insisting Jubril is Buhari” on one 9jaflaver.com

The blog claimed to have culled the excerpt of the interview from The Sun Newspaper, but The ICIR could not find the interview on the newspaper’s website. 

The picture resurfaced on popular microblogging site, Twitter, on 26 November 2019,  in a tweet by one Akanimo Umah @AKANIMOUmoh5. The image which was then reposted by another user on the microblogging site @navimumbaiipob on October 2, 2020, at exactly 12:08 post meridiem, has gathered 414 retweets and 242 likes as of October 20, 2020.

The post attached images purported to be of  President Buhari’s death certificate and accused Her Royal Majesty of covering up the claim and conspiracy against the actualisation of the Republic of Biafra, a secessionist state that existed from May 1967 to January 1970 during Nigeria civil war.

The ‘clone’ conspiracy theory

At the height of the anxiety about the president’s health in 2017, there were speculations of the president’s rumoured death flying across the country. Popular among the speculations was the one pushed by Nnamdi Kanu, leader of the Indigenous People of Biafra (IPOB). 

By comparing Buhari’s pre- and post-medical leave physique, Nnamdi Kanu advanced that Buhari had died and had been replaced by a lookalike who he called “Jubril” from Sudan. 

Since making the claim, several social media users have been reposting that president Buhari is an impostor with varying pictures to question his identity.

Although Nnamdi Kanu did not provide evidence to back the claim, he later denied making such an accusation.

However, the president, while responding to the claim in a town hall in Poland where he attended a United Nations climate conference,  regarded those peddling the false information as “ignorant and irreligious” people.

Discussions about the conspiracy rested from online arguments prior to the 2019 elections. But due to the protracted silence of the President over the Lagos Lekki shooting of the armless #EndSARS protesters, Nigerian netizens brought back the argument while many people fell for it. 

Sorting the fictional letter

The ICIR again conducted a search for media evidence of the Queen’s correspondence with Nigeria between  2017 to 2020.

The earliest correspondence found by The ICIR was the letter written by the Queen to felicitate with Nigeria on the occasion of her sixtieth independence anniversary.

The letter which was conveyed to the presidency by the British High Commission in the country called for a stronger bond between Nigeria and the United Kingdom.

“It gives me great pleasure to offer my warmest congratulations on the 60th anniversary of Nigeria’s Independence, together with my best wishes for your country’s continued happiness and prosperity,” the message read.

“The United Kingdom and Nigeria benefit from strong and enduring ties as Commonwealth partners through shared history and most importantly, our people. These are bonds that I hope and believe will flourish long into the future.” she wrote

Also, the featured image attached to the claim was used when Her Majesty signed the European Withdrawal Act which gave royal assent to the United Kingdom’s exit from the European Union on June 27, 2018. Our investigation also showed that the picture which was copyrighted to Wikimedia (Chatham House) has been used multiple times to illustrate events involving the monarch.

The ICIR also subjected the featured image to a metadata tool and it revealed that the picture was taken on 18th November 2014 at exactly 6:17 pm with NIKON D800 (camera) and by Ian Enness, a freelance photographer. 

Screenshot of President Muhammadu Buhari while addressing the nation on the #EndSARS protest on Oct 22, 2020

Conclusion

Based on the above findings, the claim that Queen Elizabeth II wrote a condolence letter is baseless and FALSE, just as the returning of the claim that failure of Buhari to address the #EndSARS protests on time does not constitute a sufficient condition to mislead citizens on the same issue that had been resolved since 2018.

The report was produced during the 2020 Dubawa Fellowship attended by the reporter. 

WTO election: EU endorses Nigeria’s Okonjo-Iweala, as US backs her South Korean counterpart

ALL 27 European Union (EU) governments have thrown their weight behind Nigeria’s Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala to head the World Trade Organization (WTO) against Yoo Myung-hee, her South Korean counterpart.

Myung-hee, South Korea’s trade chief, who is also the only other contender for the position of heading the global trade body, has gained the support of the United States (US), Bloomberg reports.

Both women are the two left in a race of becoming the director-general of WTO – a race that began with eight contestants from different countries across the world.

At a time of uncertainty – the coronavirus pandemic and waged trade war between the US and China, the future DG, who is to be elected by November 7 has a huge task ahead.

Roberto Azevedo, the former DG of the global trade body stepped down in August – a year before the end of his tenure, giving rise to the need for a new lead especially as the Geneva-based trade body faces unprecedented times.

The WTO is an International organisation established in 1995 to deal with the global rules of trade between nations, pushing for a coherent and smooth regulation of trade among nations of the world.

Presently, the organisation has 164-member nations and 24 observer governments.

Meanwhile, President Muhammadu Buhari has assured Okonjo-Iweala,  of the country’s full support.

“I assure you that we will do all that we can to ensure that you emerge as the Director-General of WTO, not only because you are a Nigerian, but because you are a hardworking Nigerian. You deserve this,’’ Buhari said.

Okonjo-Iweala has also gained the support of powerful bodies including the Economic Community of West Africa States (ECOWAS), which has other African and non-African countries to support her candidature.

If appointed, she would become the first woman and African to lead the most influential global trading organisation.

Nigerian policeman in US, Akintunde advises FG to review police recruitment process

AKINTAYO Akintunde, a Nigerian who is a police officer with the Washington Police Department in the United States has advised the Federal Government to review the recruitment process into the Nigeria Police Force.

Akintunde emphasised that the recruitment process into the Nigeria Police Force should be ratified, more efficient, and career-driven unlike what the situation is at the moment.

Akintunde spoke Tuesday morning while featuring on Arise television. He was speaking on the recent #ENDSARS protest against police brutality in which Nigerian youths were seeking police reforms and the disbandment of the controversial Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS) of the Nigeria Police Force.

“In Nigeria, we need to start hiring people based on their careers. Now for me, I am a police officer because I love to be a police officer, I want to help people, I want to help my community, that is the main reason I joined and most of my colleagues when we get into the hiring process, they ask us why do you want to be a police officer. I don’t think that is what they ask the Nigeria Police officers, they just put people in the Police Academy in Nigeria,” he stated.

He added that “Even if state police are created,” recruiting should the main key, noting that recruits must be assessed based on their motives to join the police.

“You have to start asking these people why they want to join the police department. If you are joining because of the money or because you want to take bribes for somebody.”

Speaking on how police officers in the US carry out their duties, Akintunde said each officer works with a manual guiding their day-to-day affairs.

“Here in my department, they gave us a manual on the procedure to raid, what to do and what not to do on and off duty,” Akintunde said.

“Some might do something wrong and they don’t get caught but when you get caught, you are suspended. Sometimes you are suspended without pay and if the crime is really wrong, you get terminated.”

On the process of monitoring and holding police officers accountable for their actions, Akintunde said all officers in the US are being monitored by their superiors.

“Everybody is being monitored by somebody, you have sergeant monitoring the officer, lieutenant monitoring the sergeant, the captain monitoring the lieutenant,” he said.

“So there is kind of a managerial process that is going on and it is very effective, as a DC officer, I don’t have the right to go to Maryland and arrest someone because that is another jurisdiction.”

On the Prison break in Edo State and incarceration of awaiting trial suspects, Akintunde who had worked as a US Correctional officer said citizens of the country are not incarcerated when awaiting trial for committing petty crimes.

“In the American Correctional Service, if you are awaiting trial, they put you in jail and if your crime is not like a felony, they put you back on the street and then you await your trial before you get a date for trial in court,” he said.

“Putting people in jail for trial for long is not good at all because I went to Europe to conduct research on Criminal Justice Reform and I went to London Prison, I found out that London only had 698 persons in prison as of 2015 while the US has 1.2 million.”

“They usually put people in community service. We can even use the people who have committed petty crimes to clean up the street and save money instead of taking them to prison where they might meet bigger criminals to teach them to how to commit bigger crimes. They might turn to be a high-class criminal when they come out,” he added.

When asked to speak about the welfare of police officers in the US, he said the officers are paid wages rather than the salary that the Nigeria Police officers are paid.

“On Police welfare, the cost of living is compared to our salary because we have a union that fights for us, that compare our cost of living to our salary and we get paid every two weeks, unlike Nigeria where they pay them at the end of the month.”

He added that there is health insurance available to the officers in the US adding that there is a 25 years’ retirement plan for them.

“I recommend every officer in Nigeria to have health insurance. They have children and wives. If you don’t pay them the salary they are bound to take bribes.

“Their quality of life is the main thing. We do psychological tests every day, if you think there is something wrong, we have a psychologist that we can go to. They need to start encouraging people to join the police,” Akintunde said.

He noted that the Nigerian government should not replace the defunct SARS unit with the new SWAT stating that if there would be a SWAT team, it should not come as a replacement for SWAT.

Among the five demands of the ENDSARS protesters in Nigeria is the increase in the payment of the police officers in  Nigeria.

The protesters demanded that the government should prioritise police welfare, get justice for the victim of police brutality, disband the SARS unit, among others.