Home Blog Page 2095

Untold stories of Abuja waste collectors who work daily despite the risk of COVID-19

This report tells the stories of over 20 waste collectors in Abuja who through their disregard for protective measures expose themselves to the danger of contracting COVID-19 and pose danger to the customers they serve.


CUSTOMER! Mai dust bin!” Aminu Sani, from Zamfara State, calls out to prospective customers as he moves from one apartment to another with his old brown wheelbarrow in search of wastes.

He repeatedly hits his barrow with a tiny iron to attract residents who may want to dispose of their wastes.

Akoi, dust bin,” meaning – “Yes, I have a dust bin” – the usual response Sani gets once a resident indicates interest.


READ ALSO:

He visits various neighbourhoods daily to pick bags of refuse, which are later deposited at dumpsites located at Gosa, Mpape, or Idu in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT). He renders this service for amounts not less than N30.

Sani collects all manners of domestic and medical wastes, without protecting himself, thereby posing risks to himself and the residents he serves.

 

Aminu Sani waste collector visits residential areas along with a friend around neighbourhoods around the Umar Yar’dua Highway Airport Road, Abuja in search of wastes Photo Credit: Olugbenga Adanikin, The ICIR

Abu Ali, another waste collector sits nearby a power transmission facility at the Umaru Musa Yar’dua highway, towards the Abuja City Gate.

He gazed at a filled waste container a few metres to the electric installation near the dumpsite.

More than 20 of his friends, he said, have just returned to the northern part of the country because they suffered from malaria fever, cough, and chest pain. Six of them left Abuja earlier while others followed shortly after. “But, I could not reach out to them to ascertain their current health status. My phone was already stolen,” he told the reporter.

Ali, 22, an indigene of Katsina State, Baure Local Government Area arrived Abuja in 2011. He has colleagues who also came from Zamfara, and Kano to make a living in the FCT. They are all involved in the informal business of waste collection, but none wears PPE.

While the Abuja Environment Protection Board (AEPB) focuses on highbrow areas such as Central Business District, Maitama, Wuse, Gwarimpa to mention but a few, Ali’s friends visit neighbourhoods and locations left uncovered by the AEPB. They are also paid N30 for each bag of waste, like Sani.

But, unlike Ali and his friends who collect waste from residential areas, other scavengers only stop at the dumpster by the major roads. They sort the collected wastes and pick items such as Aluminium materials,  plastic bottles, cans and other metallic objects sold for recycling purposes.

Though waste scavenging has been banned in the city centres in 2018, experts believe that the waste scavengers play a significant role in the circular economy, promoting waste recycling as a form of achieving the Sustainable Development Goal (SDGs) in 2030.

 

Scavengers in the face of COVID-19

Shortly after the FCT recorded its first case of the COVID-19, six of Ali’s friends who were waste scavengers became ill. While Ali could not ascertain whether their ailments were COVID-19 related, he assumes so.

“…We have a lot of our people who are into this waste collection job. We are up to 50. Suddenly, some became very sick and patronised local chemists,  Ali told The ICIR.

“They went to the chemist for medications but there was no improvement. They used herbs and it was still the same.”

He believes they might have contracted the virus while visiting different homes to pick up wastes, which, he said usually include disposed face masks, hand gloves, medical wastes and other unclean items.

 

Teenage waste collectors at another dump within the AMAC area. Photo Credit: Olugbenga Adanikin, The ICIR

Ali and Usman Mohammed, 27, expressed anger that he and his colleagues are exposed to danger that nobody cared about.

There are scores of waste collectors across the FCT, working in the frontline of the battle against the Covid-19 pandemic. And they continue to work despite movement restrictions.

Proper hygiene, safety kits vital to keeping safe amidst pandemic

Since the outbreak of the global pandemic in Wuhan China, late 2019, the World Health Organisation (WHO) recommended the use of face masks, hand gloves, and social distancing as parts of safety measures. The same guidelines were adopted by the Nigeria Centre for Disease Control (NCDC).

Globally, the number of COVID-19 cases has risen to 6, 246, 018, with over 373, 348 deaths. As of 1st June in Nigeria, the total figure of confirmed cases has risen to 10,168 cases, 6,861 active cases, 3,007 recovered while 295 deaths were recorded.

So far, government responses to Covid-19 pandemic including the daily briefing by the Presidential Committee have not addressed the plights of waste collectors

 

Concept of Circular Economy, Illustration Source: UNIDO

The United Nations Industrial Development Organisation (UNIDO),  recognises waste scavengers as significant contributors in the cycle of waste management. An Environmentalist, Nnimmo Bassey, believes that waste collectors deserve government attention and economic support. He says they play a significant role in keeping the environment healthy but does this without PPEs.

“They would sort and clean up solid wastes at great risk to themselves,” Bassey adds, stressing that the public waste management system in the country is still elementary.

Findings by The ICIR also revealed that few scavengers make use of hand gloves. Majority of them, including the ones approached by this reporter, do not have facemasks or other forms of protective kits. “I was advised by my brother to wear a hand glove and cover my nose to keep safe from coronavirus but it is God that protects us,” Sani told this reporter.

As he spoke, he bent and pulled out a red rubber hand glove from the corner of his wheelbarrow. But prior to the conversation with this reporter, he had no face mask or hand glove on. Yet, he pressed the waste in his wheel-barrow with his bare hands to create space for more dirt.

 

I’m done working until COVID-19 is over

Jamiu Yusuf, 23, is new in the waste collection business. But while he moves from one house to another with his wheel-barrow, he is conscious of the new danger his work poses. He would rather suspend the business of waste collection until the pandemic is over but Sani, his master, would not bulge.

 

Jamilu Yusuf 23-year-old scavenger wants to return home until COVID-19 pandemic is over.
Photo Credit: Olugbenga Adanikin, The ICIR

Findings by The ICIR reveal that most of the waste pickers still hold the belief that Covid-19 is a disease that afflicts only the rich, especially those who travel via aircraft. Their belief that God would protect them from the disease despite their non-adherence with safety measures makes them more susceptible to contracting the virus.  Among several concerns, the scavengers pleaded with the AEPB to organise the informal sector and provide supports such as training and safety kits. They also called for proper coordination and monitoring of the group, including the contractors to reduce exploitation.

 

Jamilu Yusuf stands at a strategic street waiting for that call to offtake wastes. Photo Credit: Olugbenga Adanikin, The ICIR

 

Expert opinions

Nnimmo Bassey, Executive Director, Health of Mother Earth Foundation. Photo Source: Vanguard Newspaper

Bassey, Executive Director, Health of Mother Health Foundation, however, advised a complete overhaul of the waste management system. He wants waste collectors to be recognised as service providers rather than scavengers. The government, he said, should train and supply them with PPE so they could safely engage in waste collection, segregation, and recycling.

He described the waste collectors as a critical part of health service delivery.

To him, they bear a great risk as they go round picking wastes used by everyone at various homes, oblivious of their medical status.

“Covid19 has generated a situation whereby used nose masks that ought to be treated as medical wastes are being handled like ordinary wastes. Scavengers can easily get exposed to the virus if they pick masks that had been used by infected persons,” says Bassey.

“In addition to those specific medical wastes that should be handled professionally, any waste generated by an infected person has a potential of passing on the infection to them.”

Mike Terungwa, Executive Director, Global Initiative for Food Security and Ecosystem Protection (GIFSEP)
Photo Source: Twitter

David Terungwa, Executive Director of the Global Initiative for Food Security and Ecosystem Protection (GIFSEP), acknowledged the vulnerability of waste collectors in the pandemic and how they simultaneously pose a threat to the public..

According to him, the waste collectors come in handy  and are still patronised by ‘thousands of people.’ He, however, called for proper coordination and sensitisation of the group.

“…There are reports of people picking up facemasks from dumpsites, washing and reselling them to the public. They are at risk to themselves and the general public. They should, therefore, be sensitised instead of looking at them as a nuisance to the society,” says Terungwa.

“We are as strong as our weakest link.”

AEPB – They are on their own

On 22nd May, The ICIR reached out to the AEPB to find out what assistance  it offers waste collectors in the informal sector, particularly during the pandemic, but a top official who pleaded anonymity simply said, “they [waste scavengers] are on their own.”

When asked about policy guiding the operation of informal waste collectors, AEPD official responded that only environmental health workers could respond to the question.

But the source disclosed that the AEPB has registered contractors it works with on waste collection.

“The officials in uniform you see packing wastes within the city are our contractors. The cleaning service has been contracted out…but as for the scavengers. Honestly, those ones are on their own.”

When Mrs Janet Peni, AEPB Director of Information was contacted, she promised to reach out to the staff suitable to comment on the issue.

On 24th May, she sent the mobile number of Benjamin Ewerem, AEPB Deputy Director in charge of environmental health. The ICIR directed its question to Ewerem but, again, he referred the reporter to another official at the AEPB headquarters.

On 27th May, the reporter met with Ewerem at about 11:30 am, but, again, he referred the reporter to the Administrative Head of the AEPB after listening to the questions. At the MD’s office, the secretary said the reporter would need to write officially. She advised the reporter to again speak to Mrs Peni. The ICIR eventually wrote a request letter but got no response as of the time of filing this report.

Send your children to Almajiri schools and go to jail, El-Rufai warns parents

NASIR El-Rufai, Governor of Kaduna State  has warned that parents who enroll their children into the Almajiri system of education in the state risk two-year jail term.

El-Rufai issued the stern warning when he visited some 200 Almajiri children that were repatriated from Nasarawa State to Kaduna and are undergoing rehabilitation at Government College, Kurmin Mashi.

While noting that the repatriated Almajirai are citizens of Kaduna State, the governor stated that the the state government would give them all the opportunities that they deserve to grow and develop.

He expressed satisfaction with the ongoing transformation of the Almajiri pupils from hopelessness to hope and confidence, assuring that the state would do whatever it can to give them a better future.

“We will, therefore, continue to take delivery of every Almajiri pupils indigenous to Kaduna state for rehabilitation, treatment and enrolment into formal schools nearest to where their parents live,” he said.

“We will continue to do this until we clear Kaduna state of the menace of Almajiri system, which is not education but the abuse of the privilege and future of a child.”

El-Rufai said that the ultimate goal of his administration is for the children to acquire formal education without depriving them of the opportunity to acquire Quranic education.

“They will continue their Quranic education but under the care of their parents and not under someone who does not know them or who was paid to look after them,” he said.

He explained that the Ministry of Human Services and Social Development (MHSSD), along with UNICEF would closely monitor them and ensure that no child would leave his locality until he finishes primary and junior secondary school.

He stressed that every child in Kaduna State must get a 12-year free and compulsory primary and secondary school education, adding that ‘those that cannot proceed to senior secondary school will have the opportunity to go to vocational schools, which are also free.’

Similarly, the governor threatened to prosecute any Islamic cleric who enrolls children into an Almajiri school, saying that such clerics will be jailed and fined N100,000 or N200,000 per child.

National Assembly vows it won’t back down on NDDC probe 

AKINOLA Bashiru, spokesperson of the ninth Senate, says the National Assembly will under no circumstance back down on its probe of the Niger Delta Development Commission (NDDC).

In a statement released on Twitter, Bashiru added that the Commission should provide evidence of alleged corruption claims against lawmakers of the Senate and House of Representatives to anti-graft agencies for investigation.

He maintained that no amount of blackmail against lawmakers or the institution of the National Assembly would stop ongoing investigations into the financial transactions of the Commission.

The Senate spokesperson said the attention of the Senate was drawn to a statement credited to Cairo Ojougboh, the Executive Director of Projects at the NDDC under the Interim Management Committee (IMC) in which he (Ojuogboh) alleged that senators and members of House of Representative were behind the NDDC fraud.

The NDDC had in recent times been enmeshed in corruption scandals with individuals and groups accusing the Interim Management Committee of embezzling funds meant for developmental projects through various means.

Only last Thursday, the Commission announced the death of Ibanga Bassey Etang, its acting Director of Finance and Administration,

Etang’s death came in the midst of the Forensic Audit of the NDDC ordered by President Muhammadu Buhari and the probe of the agency’s finances by the National Assembly.

Bashiru noted that the National Assembly was at a loss as to why Ojougboh has repeatedly made such allegations at a time when the NDDC was under scrutiny of forensic audit and investigation by the same National Assembly.

“Apparently, Cairo Ojougboh is ignorant of the constitutional mandate of the National Assembly to carry out oversight function over all agencies expending government resources with a view to exposing and preventing corruption, abuse and inefficiency,” Bashiru stated.

Speaking on the Constitutional responsibility of the National Assembly to perform oversight duty on the Commission, the lawmaker explained that the oversight function was aimed at facilitating rapid and sustainable development in the Niger Delta, as well as ensure the proper application of funds for the region.

Bashiru stressed that while the National Assembly is committed to reposition the NDDC to address the challenges of the Niger Delta through facilitating the rapid and sustainable development of the area,  however, it is naturally concerned about the allegations of poor management or outright fraud in the management of the funds and operations of the commission.

He added that the probe of the Commission by the National Assembly was not maliciously intended or aimed at victimizing anyone at the NDDC.

“The setting up of the investigation is predicated on the above concern and not to victimise or witch-hunt anyone. It was also in this regards that the National Assembly has accorded the executives the necessary cooperation that will facilitate the completion of the forensic audit,” he said.

He stressed that National Assembly in line with carrying out its oversight functions, “will appraise the budget and its operations of the Commission like other agencies to entrench a culture of transparency and accountability.”

Taking a look at the Commission over allegations of corruption against lawmakers, Bashiru asked the management of the Commission in view of its recent claims to make same available to the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) and the Independent Corrupt Practices Commission (ICPC) for investigation.

“Therefore, the allegations in respect of the budget clearly smacks of cheap blackmail predicated on falsehood. One would have expected an organisation of integrity to have formally made complaints to the anti-corruption agencies of the purported allegations against senators and members of House of Representatives of the NDDC committees, if there are facts to substantiate same,” he said.

“This is a very disturbing trend and the Senate will not tow this path. The proper avenue to challenge exercise of power of the National Assembly is the court of law, not spewing falsehood on pages of newspapers and electronic media.”

He further added that National Assembly will not succumb to cheap blackmail from any quarter noting that it is committed to ensuring probity and accountability of all agencies of government, no matter whose ox is gored.

 

 

Dangiwa Umar writes Buhari, says lopsided appointments spell doom for Nigeria

DANGIWA Umar, a former military governor of Kaduna State has warned that lopsided appointments by President Muhammadu Buhari into the offices of the Federal Government would ruin and bring destruction to the country.

“Mr President, I regret that there are no kind or gentle words to tell you that your skewed appointments into the offices of the federal government, favouring some and frustrating others, shall bring ruin and destruction to this nation,” Umar,  a retired Colonel, said in an open letter to the president.

Umar’s Open Letter “Mr President Please Belong To All Of Us, addressed to President Buhari was dated  May 30, 2020 and personally signed by him.

In the letter, the vocal retired Colonel lamented that appointments made by the president gave undue preferences to some sections of the country at the expense of others even as he added that this is more pronounced in the leadership cadre of security services.

According to him, Nigeria has become “dangerously” polarized and risk sliding into crisis on account of these appointments.

While citing instances of appointment patterns of the then NPC-led Federal Government between 1965 and 1976, he said,” Mr President, as a witness and beneficiary, it is our expectation that you would emulate these great acts of statesmanship. Which is why we have continued to engage with you.”

He pointed out that the enthusiasm for celebrating his 5th year in office was not shared equally by the public.

Umar pointed out that many segments of the public were convinced that the president’s five years in office have not met the yearnings, expectations and change promised Nigerians.

However, he urged Buhari to check the lapses stating that his achievements at the end of eight years would not be measured solely by the physical infrastructure built by his administration but through intangible things” like how much you uplifted the spirit and moral tone of the nation.

“How well have you secured the nation from ourselves and from external enemies?” he added.

Umar stated that he was prompted to write the open letter, by the loud sounds of drums, singing and dancing that erupted within many groups in the last few days on the grounds that the president attained the 5th year in office as President of Nigeria.

“It comes as no surprise that enthusiasm for the celebration is not shared equally by segments of the public. While your admirers and supporters believe you have performed well, many others believe the five years you have been in office as our President has not met the yearnings, expectations and change promised Nigerians,” he said.

Still dwelling on the appointments made by the president, the former governor of Kaduna State further stated that the president should not gloss over the chaos that has overtaken appointments into government offices in his administration.

“All those who wish you and the country well must mince no words in warning you that Nigeria has become dangerously polarized and risk sliding into crisis on account of your administration’s lopsided appointments which continues to give undue preference to some sections of the country over others,” Umar said.

“Nowhere is this more glaring than in the leadership cadre of our security services.”

 

Omozuwa: Amnesty International says govt response to rape cases woefully inadequate

THE Amnesty International says the poor response of Nigerian government to rising cases of rape across the country was encouraging perpetrators, describing government’s response as “woefully inadequate.”

The rights organisation stated this while condemning the rape and brutal murder of Vera Omozuwa, a 22-year-old 100-level student of the University of Benin, Edo State.

Omozuwa was raped and killed inside a Redeemed Christian Church of God in Benin city on  Saturday, May 30.

In a  statement released on its official Twitter page, the organisation stated that although rape is a crime in Nigeria, government’s response to it continues to be, woefully inadequate.

It lamented that Omozuwa was raped and killed at a time the ‘nation was still coming to terms with the gross violation, in Jigawa State where 11 men were arrested for raping a 12-year old girl at Limawa in Dutse, the state capital.

Amnesty International attributed the rising cases of rape across Nigeria to the failure of law enforcement agencies to ensure that rapists face justice.

“We are deeply concerned that perpetrators of rape in Nigeria invariably escape punishment,” the organisation said, calling on the Nigerian authorities to strongly discard discriminatory laws that condone rape or prevent its successful prosecution.

The tragic incident,  according to Omozuwa’s friends, saw her attackers smashing her head with a fire extinguisher and leaving her unconscious around the Ikpoba Hill area of Benin City, the state capital.

Although she was rushed to the intensive care unit of a hospital,  Omozuwa died shortly due to the degree of injuries she sustained.

Friends and all those, who knew her closely during her lifetime, have been paying tributes and calling for the perpetrators of the crime to be brought to justice.

“It is with a heavy heart that I announce the passing away of our loved one, friend, sister and course mate.

“She was raped on her way home from church and had her head smashed with a fire extinguisher in broad day light around Ikpoba Hill, Benin City. This happened yesterday, May 30, 2020,”  one of her friends wrote on social media.

 

 

 

SERAP to Buhari: Show us the spending details of all loans taken since 2015, list of projects

THE Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP)  has asked President Muhammadu Buhari, to make public  the spending details of all loans his administration has taken since 2015 when he was inaugurated.

The organisation also requested the president to include in the detail, list of projects, amount of loans since 1999, repayment conditions.

SERAP tweeted on Sunday that if the president was able to meet up with its request which also include to audit all the loans, it would remove opacity, improve transparency and public trust in his administration.

This followed a Freedom of Information (FoI) request by the organisation sent to the president on Saturday in which it made those requests.

The FoI request sent yesterday, read: “While governments since 1999 have borrowed money in the name of Nigeria and its citizens, much of the funds have reportedly been mismanaged, stolen or squandered, leaving the citizens with the burden of having to repay these loans,” SERAP wrote on Twitter.

The requests are according to SERAP are “Details of the spending of loans obtained by your government since May 29, 2015, including specific details of projects and locations of the projects as well as the conditions of any such projects.

“Total amount of debts that have so far been incurred by your government, including the interest rate, the details of debts inherited from the previous administrations, and details of refinancing of any such loans, as well as any strategy put together on borrowing decisions, and to promote sustainable borrowing.

“Wether any public officials solicited and/or received bribes in the negotiations for any of the loans.”

In the letter signed by Kolawole Oluwadare, SERAP deputy director,  the organisation urged the Nigerian leader to use his leadership position and the opportunity of the fifth year anniversary of his government to grant its request.

Few weeks ago, SERAP  sent an open letter Buhari urging him to use his “leadership position to follow the ‘Namibia example’ by urgently issuing an executive order to ban the purchase of new cars by the presidency, and all ministers for the remainder of the tenure of your administration, that is, until May 2023.”

It will be recalled that President Buhari had last week sought the National Assembly’s approval for a fresh loan of $5.513bn, reportedly to fund the 2020 budget deficit, critical projects, and support some states.

The National Assembly had also recently approved a loan of N850 billion  for the president while another loan of $22.79billion, already approved by the Senate, is pending before the House of Representatives.

SERAP said: “Opacity in the spending of loans would continue to have negative impacts on the fundamental interests of citizens. Transparency would ensure that the loans are not diverted to private pockets, increase public trust that these loans would be used to benefit Nigerians, provide good value for money, and reassure Nigeria’s creditors.”

According to SERAP, “Rather than taking more loans and increasing Nigeria’s debts burden to fund the opulent lifestyles of former state governors receiving life pensions, we urge you to cut the costs of governance, including by obeying the judgment ordering your government to challenge the legality of states’ pension laws, and to recover pensions collected by former governors.”

SERAP also expressed “concerns about the massive and growing national debts, and the negative impacts on socio-economic development as well as access of Nigerians to public goods and services, including quality education, adequate healthcare, clean water, and regular electricity supply.”

The FoI request, read in part: “While access to loans can provide indispensable resources, the mismanagement and squandering of any such resources would be counter-productive. Nigerians should no longer be made to repay debts incurred in their name but which have not benefited them in any manner, shape or form.”

“Any unresolved allegations of mismanagement, bribery and corruption in the use of loans would continue to deprive millions of Nigerians access to basic public goods and services, and would leave your government without the resources to respond to the COVID-19 crisis.”

“We would be grateful if the requested information is provided to us within 7 days of the receipt and/or publication of this letter. If we have not heard from you by then, the Registered Trustees of SERAP shall take all appropriate legal actions under the Freedom of Information Act to compel you to comply with our request.”

“We urge you to ensure that those suspected to be responsible for any mismanagement and corruption are promptly referred to appropriate anti-corruption agencies for further investigation, and where there is relevant admissible evidence, prosecution.”

“Transparency and accountability in the spending details of all the loans that have so far been obtained by your government, and those obtained by previous administrations would mean that the loans can help Nigeria to overcome its acute development challenges, reduce the possibility of mismanagement and corruption.”

“It would also help to avoid a morally repugnant result of visiting the sins of corrupt governments and officials on innocent Nigerians.”

“We also urge you to promptly instruct Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission (ICPC) and Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) to monitor the spending of all loans obtained since the assumption of office in May 2015.”

 

 

FG slashes health budget, leaves legislature’s library and constituency projects intact

Aderemi Ojekunle


THE Federal government has cut the budget of the Ministry of Health and other key ministries such as education, power, and agriculture. This is amidst the ravaging COVID-19 pandemic and inadequate health infrastructure in the country. However, in what seems like the Executive arm patronising the Legislative arm, the Zonal Intervention Project budget and the National Assembly Library budget were untouched.

According to the revised document seen by Dataphyte, the Federal Ministry of Health had a downward cut of ₦15.17 billion. Likewise, the Ministries of Education, Science and Technology, Water Resources, and the Federal Capital Territory are also among the worst hit by capital expenditure reductions.

Since the outbreak of coronavirus, governments around the world are adjusting to current economic realities. The global economic shock arising from the pandemic has resulted in the fall of crude oil prices and production. This development led to various adjustments in the early passed 2020 budget, which is pending a review from the National Assembly. Details from the revision showed that the Federal Government reduced the benchmark for the oil price to $25 per barrel, oil production at 1.90 million barrel per day, exchange rate devalued to ₦360 to a dollar.

No ₦1.5 trillion Cut But Increased Recurrent Expenditure

The Federal Government had announced its decision to downsize the entire 2020 budget by ₦1.5trillion. However, the revised budget proposal is only short by ₦80.35 billion (80,345,966,946). According to the proposed budget document, the 2020 budget as passed by the National Assembly was ₦10.59 trillion (10,594,362,364,830) while the proposed revision is ₦10.51 trillion (10,509,654,033,054).

Further analysis of the budget revision showed that despite reductions in capital expenditure of key MDAs, such as Health, Education, and Agriculture, the federal government increased recurrent expenditure by ₦85.55 billion. This is from ₦4.84 trillion to ₦4.93 trillion.

Capital Expenditure of N100 billion for Zonal Intervention Project, others remain unchanged

Despite cuts in key critical sectors, the Federal Government left N2 billion for the construction of the National Assembly Library (NLIDS). Ordinarily, this should have been among the opportunity costs on the expenditure items as a result of dwindling revenue and projected recession.

Other capital expenses not touched include ₦4 billion expenses for Galaxy Blackbone, ₦5 billion for GIFMIS/IPPIS Capital, ₦6 billion for OSSAP: Special Projets, ₦16 billion for OSSAP: Social Safety Net, N10billion for Office of the Senior Special Adviser to the President (OSSA): Conditional Grants To States, ₦8 billion for OSSAP: Payment of Ongoing Projects, ₦7.97 billion for OSSAP – SDGs: SDG Projects 1.  Also, ₦100 billion for Zonal Intervention Projects, ₦2.5 billion for Head of Service (Federal Government Staff Housing Loans Board), ₦1.5 billion for National Development Plans (Federal Ministry of Finance, Budget, and National Planning), and ₦7.2 billion for Capital Existencies/Adjustment to Capital Cost.

It also includes ₦10 billion for Contingency (Capital), ₦500 million for Presidential Enabling Business Environment Council (PEBEC), ₦10 billion for Grants to Bank of Industry (BOI) to support low-interest lending to SMEs, ₦26.9 billion for Refund (Acquisition of Yola DISCO), ₦20 billion for Special Intervention Fund, N1 billion for Constitution review, N500 million for CPA, ₦1.5 billion for FGN Intervention In Zamfara/Katsina/Borno, and another ₦2.5 billion for the Digitalisation of Archival for Supreme Court Proceedings and Judgments.

MDAs with Biggest Cuts in Capital Expenditure

The Ministry of Works and Housing got the highest cut of N58.83 billion. The Ministry’s capital expenditure was dropped from ₦315.57 billion to ₦256.74 billion. The Ministry is followed by the Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development with a revised capital expenditure from ₦124.4 billion to ₦79 billion.

The Ministry of Transport also suffered a similar fate with ₦14.71 billion cut, while Science and Technology Ministry got ₦20.47 billion cut. Also, capital expenditure for the Ministry of Education was cut by ₦16.86 billion, FCTA and the Presidency removed ₦32. 75 billion and ₦9.1 billion, respectively.

The Federal Government also cut ₦111.92 million from the Office of the Auditor General of the Federation, leaving the important component of government with a meagre ₦41.15 million from the initial ₦153.07 million.

Nigeria’s fiscal policy continues to favour recurrent expenditure

The new budget revision suggests the extent of the Federal Government’s commitment to development aspirations. Capital expenditure includes the acquisition and development of infrastructure facilities, maintenance of fixed assets, and others. Contrarily, recurrent expenditure is spent on wages and daily recurring operations. In actual sense, Nigeria’s fiscal policy continues to give high priorities to recurrent expenditure and provisions for debt servicing in place of capital expenses over the years. Although Mrs. Zainab Ahmed, Nigeria’s Minister of Finance, Budget, and National Planning, had claimed in a memo that the revision eliminated non-critical capital expenditure, classified as Administrative Capital Expenditure.

A recent DATAPHYTE occasional paper confirmed Nigeria’s bloated recurrent expenditure. The paper revealed how five key sectors received less than a fifth of the total budget size, while allocation to debt servicing was over 25 percent. For the period, capital expenditure received a meagre percentage.

In an interview with Ms. Aanu Rotimi, the Program Manager at Health Reform Foundation of Nigeria (HEFRON), she said an in-depth review of the constituency projects has shown huge investment in irrelevant projects. She stressed the same budget allocation should not be left untouched “when we are yet to have at least one functional primary healthcare centre per ward”. She then called on the National Assembly to prioritise budget response to the challenges of inadequate human resource for health, poor health infrastructure, inadequate supply of consumables which are leaving mothers and children to die in thousands annually.

Speaking with Mr. Olanrewaju Suraju, Chairman of HEDA Resource Centre, he decried the attempt to leave the legislature’s budget untouched. He said there is no direct bearing or urgent need for a National Assembly Library. It would be better to redeem the National Library than to construct the National Assembly library at this time. Leaving these items in the legislatures’ budget untouched suggest a motivation to negotiate quick passage of the revised budget” he said. He further called on the Senate President and the Speaker of the House of Representatives to ensure that non-essential components are removed from the budget revision.

This report was originally published by DATAPHYTE

AEDC official Nura Salisu impregnates teenager in FCT, dumps baby in unknown place

THE officers of Mabushi Police station, located in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), headed by Divisional Police Officer, SP Bello Saadu, have arrested a certain Nura Salisu, accused of raping, impregnating 16-year-old Nanket Manasseh and reportedly killing their baby.

Salisu, 30, an Abuja Electricity Distribution (AEDC) official, who resides in Jahi, was arrested by officers of Jahi Police station on May 22,  for abducting his 6-month-old baby and refusing to share details of its whereabouts.

The ICIR gathered that Salisu fathered the baby in question after having carnal knowledge of 16-year-old Manasseh, when she was 15.

Manasseh, who lives with her foster mother, Phoebe, in Jahi disclosed that Salisu had been chasing  her since she was 10. Recalling how he enticed her, Manasseh told The ICIR that her first encounter with him was when she was in primary three, when he gifted her a mobile phone.

Since she was not expected to own a phone, she lied to her foster mother that she found it on the floor, but Phoebe doubted her story.

When she later confessed that Salisu gave her the phone, Phoebe warned the AEDC worker to stay away from her child who at the time was only 10.  She also reported the case to the Chief of Jahi, who  warned  Salisu to keep away from the teenager.

By the time Manasseh clocked 15 and was ready for school, Salisu struck again and this time, he lured her with a promise to sponsor her education.

According to the young girl, Salisu booked a hotel and asked her to check in, claiming that he had very important information to share with her.

While in the hotel located somewhere in Jahi, Manasseh said Salisu showed up late at night and forcefully slept with her.

16-year-old Nanket Manasseh
CREDIT: Wanda Adu

“I told him I didn’t want sex but he still had me and left when he was done. In the morning I packed my things and went back to my sister’s house without telling anyone about what happened.” Manasseh narrated to The ICIR.

Two months later, Manasseh noticed that she had missed her period twice in a row and suspected that she had become pregnant . The young girl confided in her friend who advised her to abort it, but Manasseh decided to keep the child without telling her parents.  .

However, by the fourth month, Manasseh’s stomach began protruding and it caught the attention of Phoebe who quizzed her about it and made her take a Do-It-Yourself (DIY) home pregnancy test, with the aid of a test stick.

The instant test came out positive and that’s when things got worse.

With her secret discovered, Manasseh admitted that Salisu was responsible for her pregnancy and Phoebe immediately reached out to him with the news.

Unperturbed, Salisu gave Phoebe one condition of accepting the baby, saying if Manasseh put to bed in November 2019 – which by his calculations fell on the ninth month from when he last slept with her – he would accept the child. Otherwise, he wouldn’t.

On November 13, 2019, Manasseh delivered a baby boy who Salisu later named Kamal. But he was an absent father and never provided any support for the baby or its mother.

At 16, Manasseh was therefore saddled with raising the child without the support of its father except for that offered by her foster parents. 

On two separate occasions, she visited the family home of Salisu with her baby, hoping to make him provide some form of support for the baby. Yet, the more Manasseh was trying to get the best for her son from the man who put her in family way, the more Salisu was getting upset.

Salisu was married to another young lady who had four children for him, but they are all dead now.  He believes that touching his offsprings before their first birthday spelt doom, and this is the reason he avoided Kamal.

On May 21, things took a wilder turn.

Kamal had started teething and on that day and was running temperature. Worried about the health of her baby, Manasseh needed money to buy drugs for the child and acting on advice of her foster parents, she took the child to Salisu to get support.

Upon arriving at the house, Manasseh met no one and decided to stay at her friend, Blessing’s place. While there, she called  Salisu to inform him about the baby’s condition and the plan to get him to offer some support. Salisu later showed up at Blessing’s house around noon and forcefully collected the baby from its mother, and took it to an unknown place.

6-month-old Kamal missing since May 21 after being abducted by his father, Nura Salisu
CREDIT: Wanda Adu

“Salisu dragged my baby from me, holding him with one hand. I tried to collect my baby but he started walking away with the child. I didn’t see him for some time and when he came back he couldn’t tell me where he kept my baby.” Manasseh narrated in tears.

On the night of the same day, the matter of the missing baby was reported to Jahi police station.

The next day, it was transferred to Mabushi police station, where Salisu was detained and questioned about the location of the baby.

According to Phoebe, Salisu gave three different accounts on the whereabouts of the child. In one confession he admitted dumping the baby in Jabi Lake and leaving it to drown.

In the other, he claimed that he gave the child to a friend of his, Moses, who on the same day traveled to Kano with the child. Salisu said he had no means of reaching his friend or had any idea where in Kano the friend had taken baby Kamal.

In another account, Salisu said he gave the child to his sister in Garki and when asked to lead the police family to the place, he refused.

Due to varying, conflicting accounts of the child’s whereabouts, the police transferred the case from Mabushi Police Station to the state Criminal Investigation Department (CID) office for further investigation.

According to SP Bello Saadu, the DPO of Mabushi Police Station, the primary concern of the police is to locate the baby, afterwhich, Salisu would answer for his actions.

“We would work on prosecuting the suspect for all his sins,” Saadu told The ICIR on Wednesday.

At the state CID office, a new Investigation Police Officer (IPO) identified as Josephine was assigned to the case and according to Lere P. Samuel, a relation of Manasseh, on Friday, the suspect led the police to a location where he claimed to have dumped the baby.

“The IPO, Josephine was recording as Salisu told us that he left the baby wrapped in a jacket and sellotape in the bush but nothing was found,” Samuel told The ICIR.

Salisu was then taken back to the CID office where he appeared before the Assistant Inspector General of Police (Intelligence division) for more questioning.

According to Samuel, the senior officer demanded that the suspect hand over his cell phone unlocked. Upon refusal, Salisu was beaten by some officers for not cooperating and he was forced to unlock his phone.

“The ACP (intelligence division) accused Salisu of not being a true Muslim and told him the only way his punishment would be reduced is if the baby is found. He told him that in a case the baby is dead, he (Salisu) should consider himself a dead man within the next three months,” Samuel narrated the incident to The ICIR.

The ICIR  contacted the FCT Commissioner of Police Bala Ciroma on telephone but he advised that the FCT Police Public Relations Officer (PPRO), Anjuguri Manzah be contacted instead.

Manzah on his part promised to get back to our reporter after answering two calls placed to his mobile phone but as at the time of filing this report, he’s yet to respond.

The suspect remains in police custody and investigation is said to be on-going.

Meanwhile, Wanda Adu Foundation, a non-governmental organisation (NGO) focused on helping vulnerable women and children, has been monitoring the case.

While it applauds the police for transferring the case to the state CID office, the founder of the NGO, Wandadaku Adu, told The ICIR that the police have resorted to victim blaming.

“The police are blaming the victim for seeking child support. They said Manasseh’s request triggered the suspect’s actions. This is wrong and I frown at it,” she said.

She believes the police can do much more than it is doing at the moment.

With 55 per cent slash in Education, 42 percent in Health, Executive undercuts development priorities

By, Paul ADEYEYE


A REVIEW of the Revised 2020 Budget exclusively obtained by DATAPHYTE indicates that the Federal Government has reduced the total budget size by only ₦84.71 billion. Against the background that the government initially proposed a ₦1.5 trillion budget cut (over 14 percent reduction of the total budget size), the new cut is low. 

On a close look, the revision proposes less than one percent reduction to the initial budget size. With less than one percent budget reduction, one wonders the real essence of the whole budget review attempt. In addition, the budget review dampens the hope of many the Nigerians optimistic of a reduction of the enormous cost of governance. Budget for the National Assembly only reduced by 10 percent while the budget for the Presidency reduced by only 9.75 percent.

Revised 2020 Budget across Main Expenditure Items

 

 

The composition of the revised budget implies more dilemma for Nigeria’s development aspiration. Across Nigeria’s four main expenditure items, only the budgetary provisions for statutory transfers and capital expenditure have been reduced. While statutory transfers decreased by 28.9 percent, capital expenditure reduced by close to 10 percent. Against the background that budgetary provision to development propellants continue to be low, the reduction is not satisfactory.

But the bigger dilemma bothers on Nigeria’s priority. While budgetary allocation to the National Judicial Council, National Assembly, Independent National Electoral Commission, and other agencies of government have been reduced only by about 10 percent respectively, budgetary provision for education reduced by close to 55 percent. Similarly, provision for basic health care fund reduced by over 42 percent.

With the reality of the COVID-19 pandemic, reduction in budgetary share for education and healthcare does not reflect the prioritization of the citizen’s real needs. With the growing number of COVID-19 cases in the country, an increase in budget share to the health sector is expected. To expand education access to the teeming Nigerian school children who are deprived of education during this period, additional budgetary commitment is also required. This is to cover up the cost of setting up virtual learning alternatives.

Revised Budgetary Allocation to Statutory Transfer

Increased Recurrent and Debt Servicing Expenditure

Contrarily, budget share for recurrent expenditure as well as debt servicing has increased. By implication, spending on recurrent items will continue to suppress Nigeria’s aspirations for development this year. But there are even bigger questions on the items that have increased the recurrent expenditure figure. For instance, insensitive recruitments like that of the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation would have added to these expenditure burdens. Also, the increasing budgetary commitment to debt servicing over health and education may affirm that Nigeria indeed cares more about its debt profile than the citizens.

Conversely, Nigeria’s revenue realities continue to expose the need for stiffer revenue management measures. In fact with the realities presented by the Addendum to the 2020-2022 Medium Term Expenditure Framework and Fiscal Strategy Paper (MTEF/FSP), the proposed budget revision appears like a mere child’s play. As at Q1 2020, gross oil and gas revenue was short by over 28 percent of the anticipated revenue.

In addition, the net oil and gas revenue inflow to the Federation Account was ₦940.91 billion. This represents a shortfall of ₦425.52 billion (or 31.1 percent of the pro-rata amount). Similarly, non-oil tax revenue was only ₦269.41 billion by the end of the first quarter of 2020. This is a shortfall of about 40 percent of the predicated non-oil revenue earning for 2020.

From the revenue earnings in Q1 2020, as well as the existing realities on oil trade and the ongoing global pandemic, hopes for increased revenue earnings may be blurry. The continued lockdown is expected to impact on tax revenue from Nigeria’s business community. Thus, the revised budget may be somewhat impracticable without a corresponding increase in Nigeria’s debt.

Counting on the National Assembly To Do Better

At this point, the National Assembly must step in to show solidarity to the Nigerian people. Therefore, it must use its oversight powers to ensure the proposed budgetary revision is jettisoned and replaced with a more realistic and citizen-focused budget. Increasing commitment to capital investments will show Nigeria’s commitment to the course of development. DATAPHYTE’s recent occasional paper provides a guide for the budget revision.

Moreover, the legislative arm needs to show it is truly not patronised by the executive arm of government. Especially as the Zonal Intervention Project budget and the National Assembly Library budget tied to the two chambers were untouched in the budget revision. Above all, a budget that allows for increasing provision for basic education and healthcare should be developed.

In an interview with a health advocate, Ms. Aanu Rotimi, the Program Manager at Health Reform Foundation of Nigeria (HEFRON), she said the current COVID-19 situation has revealed proper investment in the health sector is central to economic growth and development. “Nothing can be more important now than appropriate and focused investment in human development according to the current realities and the future needs of this country”, she further stressed. The health advocate said this is the time to push aside superfluity of a few for direct and impactful investments for all that can be tracked and validated. In conclusion, she nudged the legislatures to walk the talk, translate their commitments to actions and ensure there are no wastages as usual.”

Also reacting to the budget revision, Mr. Kolawole Oluwadare, the Deputy Director Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) said these cuts are not inevitable. He said the Nigerian government had a lot of choices as to what to cut but chose to balance the budget on the backs of the most disadvantage. “In the absence of concrete social protection for over 80 million poor Nigerians, these cuts (and what was left uncut) will not only worsen the plight of the poor but also deepen the trust deficit of citizens in government.” Mr. Oluwadare submitted.

In April, SERAP gave the President and leadership of the National Assembly 14 days to reverse the proposed illegal cut of N26.51 billion in basic healthcare budget and to cut the National Assembly and Presidency budgets instead, or face legal action.

This report was originally published by DATAPHYTE

Rights group berates SSS for detaining journalist, lawyer against court orders, demands immediate release

THE Committee for the Defence of Human Rights (CDHR), a human rights group based in Lagos has condemned the unlawful detention of Kufre Carter, a journalist and Emperor Ogbonna, a lawyer by the State Security Service (SSS) in Akwa Ibom and Abia states respectively.

Osagie Obayuwana, National President of CDHR in a press statement made available to The ICIR condemned the continued ‘unlawful detention of  Kufre Carter by the SSS’ at Uyo, Akwa-Ibom State Command, despite being granted bail by the court and  having perfected the bail conditions.

Carter was arrested on April 27 by operatives of SSS  in Uyo. He was charged with criminal defamation for allegedly “castigating” Dominic Ukpong, the Akwa Ibom State Commissioner for Health, for his alleged poor handling of the fight against the COVID-19 pandemic in the state.

Obayuwana noted that Kufre was arraigned before a Magistrate Court, but granted bail on rather harsh conditions.

According to him, his lawyers appealed against the conditions and secured a variation of the conditions at the High Court, lamenting that after perfecting the bail conditions, Kufre was still ‘being held unlawfully in the custody of the SSS on the ground of a directive from the State Government House.

“We of the CDHR berates the DSS as a leopard that cannot change its spots, for its persistent failure to uphold the principles of the rule of law, considering its penchant for holding of detainees, despite subsisting court orders granting the release of such detainees from custody. We call to mind the national shame the same DSS subjected Nigeria to in the Omoyele Sowore case of recent memory,” the human rights activist said.

The journalist was however released on May 27, after spending a month in SSS detention.

But Obayuwana  reiterated that the  Kufre Carter case has proved conclusively that SSS  is an agency which has no respect for the Judiciary as an independent arm of government and has no qualms or remorse in disobeying court orders.

“We will not accept a situation where the DSS refuses to accept that the liberty of all citizens, freedom of movement and freedom from unlawful detention are fundamental human rights that are constitutionally guaranteed as inalienable,” he said.

He expressed concerns about the manner in which the DSS panders to the whims and caprice of members of the Executive arm in matters already before Court, involving the constitutional rights of a citizen.

In the case of Emperor Ogbonna, Obayuwana recalled that the lawyer and human rights activist was abducted in a commando style by the DSS operatives and whisked away on March 24, 2020 from his office.

He was accused of publishing what is termed “falsehood” against Okezie Ikpeazu, the Governor of Abia State.

While he was charged to Court and released after meeting his bail conditions, Obayuwana said Ogbonna  was immediately rearrested by officials of DSS on the same day of his release, April 28.

“He is reported to have been transferred to Abuja, whilst his case is still pending before the Court in Abia,” Obayuwana said.

According to him, the lawyer has been held incommunicado in Abuja,without having contacts with his family, doctors and lawyers for weeks now.

“He has not been charged to Court or granted administrative bail for any other offence he may be suspected to have committed.”

While noting that the common thread between the case of Carter Kufre and that of Emperor Ogbonna is the expression of an opinion about public office holders, the National President of CDHR berated the SSS that it lacks the power to elevate public office holders in the Executive Arm of Government to “tin gods” beyond criticism.

He maintained that decisions and orders of court must be respected and observed in a constitutional democracy and demanded immediate and unconditional release of the lawyer.

“Thus, CDHR vehemently berates the DSS for electing to act arbitrarily, in defiance to the rule of law, in refusing to respect valid orders of competent courts restoring liberty to otherwise detained persons.”

He warned that such arbitrariness could only provoke and invite anarchy, mass resistance, insurrection, protests and outright revolution by the people who are being instigated to lose faith in the rule of law.

“The continuous detention of Kufre Carter and Emperor Ogbonna despite a valid Court Order for their release is clearly illegal, unlawful and unconstitutional. CDHR therefore further vehemently decries the level to which the DSS has degenerated, to that of being persistent violators of the rights of citizens and violators of constitutional and statutory provisions.”

“The DSS has shown itself to be tainted with unprofessionalism and eye service, failing in its responsibility as an Agency of State, to observe the fundamental human rights of citizens. We have in the past called for its disbandment; we do so again now.”

Meanwhile, in similar vein, Rule of Law and Accountability Advocacy Centre (RULAAC), an advocacy organisation, called on President Muhammadu Buhari to direct the SSS to obey court orders and operate within the rule of law.